Democracy Essay - Critical Evaluation

Joan Didion

Critical Evaluation

Democracy received critical attention for its unique narrative style—a fragmented narrative in which writer Joan Didion is herself a character in the novel. She acts as author, narrator, and reporter of this story, assembling images, recollections, and historical events relating to protagonist Inez Victor’s life in an attempt to gain meaning from them. Didion introduces herself as the author at the start of the second chapter, and from this point remains a presence, consistently disrupting the narrative and rearranging and revisiting events outside logical chronology. These are actions that ultimately disturb the novel’s coherence, and so too the reader’s ability to easily comprehend meaning.

Critics remain divided regarding the effectiveness of this strategy. Some argue that her intrusions undermine the novel’s affect, while others maintain that this destabilization of certainty and meaning was perhaps Didion’s intent: to relate her belief that the political world is one in which meaning is not certain or stable, and perhaps unknowable.

An underlying feeling of uncertainty indeed pervades the novel; as author and character, Didion herself admits that the images and recollections she holds may be problematic to the composition of a story, but she further states that one must “go with what you have.” In addition to the fragmented nature of the memories, reality and fiction are further blurred by Didion’s place in her own novel as both character and author. She recalls, for example, the moment she had first met Jack Lovett—while working with Inez at Vogue; she tells about her conversations with Harry Victor and how she had dined with Billy Dillon; she recounts article clippings and photographs depicting Paul Christian’s arrest. She details these relationships as memories, and yet the reader must also never forget that she, as the author, also is consciously constructing a fictive narrative.

This current of uncertainty applies not only to the narrative structure of the novel but also to its political implications. Throughout Democracy, Didion draws attention to the idea that individuals are reduced to mere actors on the stage of...

(The entire section is 906 words.)