In Richard Brinsley Sheridan’s time The Critic: Or, A Tragedy Rehearsed was probably best known for its bitingly satirical portrait of Sheridan’s fellow dramatist, Richard Cumberland, who was the model for Sir Fretful Plagiary. Today the play is most important for the light it sheds on what Sheridan thought of the drama prevalent in his own time. By showing the reader the insipidity of the tragedy rehearsed within the play, the laughable defense of trite dramatic devices by its author, and the comments by the actors, Sheridan lets the reader see what he thought of the state of drama during his age.
The principal theme of The Critic is the dynamic interplay of illusion and reality. The central focus is on the role language plays in that interplay. Mr. Dangle, Mr. Sneer, and Mr. Puff—the names prepare one for the spirit of the comedy—form the play’s comic center, where each character either ridicules or is ridiculed, sometimes both. The play’s themes derive from the portrayal of characters who pretend to be better than they are.
Act 1 begins the play’s attacks on fakery and moral blindness. Sneer characterizes the age as “luxurious and dissipated,” saying it is nevertheless hypocritical enough to produce a drama that ignores “the follies and foibles of society” in favor of dramatizing “the greater vices and blacker crimes of humanity.” With the arrival of Sir Fretful Plagiary, the play’s attention shifts to a type of individual author. On the pretext of repeating what newspaper reviewers have said, Sneer and Dangle attack Sir Fretful’s plagiarism, coarse language, and dullness. The play’s main target, however, is Puff and his production of The Spanish Armada, a tragedy that illustrates, in comic reversal, the play’s plea for elevated standards in the theater and for literary and personal honesty.
The second and third acts present a world within a world and a tragedy within a comedy. Puff’s play is a burlesque of the tragic spirit. One of the ways that Sheridan effects his burlesque is to mix the comic outer drama with the highly stylized language and actions of the actors in rehearsal. Puff’s understanding of the elevated world of tragedy is satirized by his play’s ridiculous actions and by the stilted, hackneyed dialogue of its characters, who bear such names...
(The entire section is 964 words.)
Want to Read More?
Subscribe now to read the rest of The Critic Critical Essays. Plus get complete access to 30,000+ study guides!