(Comprehensive Guide to Short Stories, Critical Edition)

Major Creede Halcrow is the commanding officer of a Union Army infantry regiment from Massachusetts that is in combat during the Civil War. Captain Downing Madwell commands one of Halcrow’s companies. Sergeant Caffal Halcrow, the major’s brother, is an enlisted man in Madwell’s company. When Madwell was a second lieutenant in the regiment, Caffal was such a close friend that he joined as an enlisted man in order to be with him. Although the two men had each risen in rank, it was hard to maintain their friendship because military protocol created a “deep and wide” gulf between them.

One day as the regiment is on outpost duty a mile ahead of its main unit, it is attacked in a forest but holds its ground. Major Halcrow approaches Captain Madwell and orders him to take his company forward to hold the head of a ravine until the company is recalled. Halcrow offensively suggests that if Madwell is apprehensive, he may order his first lieutenant to go into the dangerous area instead. Just as sarcastically, Madwell agrees to take command personally and expresses the hope that the major will go along—preferably on horseback—so as to present a “conspicuous” target. He adds, “I have long held the opinion that it would be better if you were dead.” A half an hour after their ordered advance, Madwell and his company are driven back with a third of their men dead or dying. The rest of the regiment has been forced back several miles. With his company...

(The entire section is 465 words.)