Summary and Analysis
“Butch Weldy,” by the American poet Edgar Lee Masters (1868-1950), describes the events leading up to and following an industrial accident in which the title character suffers the loss of his sight but seems unlikely to be compensated by his employer.
The title of the poem already suggests the kind of character the poem presents. The name Butch Weldy implies a speaker who is common, unpretentious, and probably lower class in economic background. “Butch” is probably his nickname rather than the formal name he was born with, and the fact that he is identified by this name suggests that he is unassuming, down-to-earth, and (at least before the accident) physically strong. By the time the poem was written in the early twentieth century, the noun butch had already come to suggest a “tough young man” and was also an abbreviation of butcher (see the Oxford English Dictionary). In both cases, the name implies physical strength, while the last name Weldy not only sounds like wieldy (and was an early spelling of that word) but perhaps also suggests the idea of welding. For all these reasons, the very title of the work implies a central character who is sturdy, robust, and willing to work hard. Of course, all these implications seem appropriate to the first half of the poem, even as they seem highly ironic in light of the poem’s tragic outcome.
The language of the work is simple, clear, straightforward, and accessible—exactly the kind of language one might expect a person named Butch Weldy to speak. Masters avoids rhyme (which might have made the poem seem more artificial than it now is), and he also avoids predictable line lengths or obvious metrical patterns. Thus the syllable count for the first five lines is 11, 10, 9, 9, and 8, and the meter is decidedly not iambic pentameter (the kind of meter a reader might have expected). Masters steers clear of the long, sprawling lines associated with the verse of Walt Whitman, but he is clearly a poet, like Whitman, who is interested in American vernacular speech. In that respect, this poem also resembles many poems by Carl Sandburg, and the fact that the work is a monologue makes it also resemble many of the writings of Robert Browning.
The poem’s opening line suggests that Butch Weldy was once a youthful, undisciplined free spirit. At some point, however, he “got” religion—a verb that suggests no great...
(The entire section is 1140 words.)
Want to Read More?
Subscribe now to read the rest of Butch Weldy Summary. Plus get complete access to 30,000+ study guides!