Critical Evaluation

During the first two decades of the nineteenth century, Maria Edgeworth was among the most popular and most critically admired of contemporary English novelists. Her reputation declined later in the century as standards of realism changed, although her novels helped to develop such standards. The novels of Jane Austen and Sir Walter Scott came to eclipse Edgeworth’s in the public eye, but Austen and Scott admired Edgeworth’s fiction and were influenced by it.

Edgeworth herself came to dislike Belinda, particularly its title character, whom she called “cold” and “tame”; she preferred her novels with Irish settings, such as Castle Rackrent (1800) and The Absentee (1812). As a story about a young woman who must navigate social perils on her way to the choice of a suitable husband, Belinda is in many respects a conventional novel of its time. Its structure and manner show the influence of Fanny Burney and Elizabeth Inchbald, both well-regarded late eighteenth century novelists. Belinda is distinctive, though, in her combination of virtue and independent thought and in her refusal to submit to the authority of others. She can appreciate and act on wise advice from a friend, such as that of Lady Anne Percival, but she makes her own decisions. In the novel’s last scene, the stage is set for Belinda’s acceptance of Clarence Hervey, but she delays her acceptance, reinforcing the reader’s sense that Belinda is as much her own woman at the end of the story as she was at the beginning.

Edgeworth emphasizes Belinda’s independence by juxtaposing her against three other female characters: Harriet Freke, Lady Delacour, and Virginia St. Pierre. The outrageous Harriet—cross-dressing, proclaiming women’s superiority to men, and involving herself and Lady Delacour in an attempt to influence a political campaign—is a parody of a late eighteenth century feminist. She perhaps made a contemporary reader think of the scandals that had collected by 1801 around the pioneer feminist Mary Wollstonecraft. It became known that Wollstonecraft, the author of A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), openly bore a child out of wedlock. Harriet’s characterization...

(The entire section is 911 words.)