Antigone Essay - Critical Evaluation

Jean Anouilh

Critical Evaluation

Starting in the early 1930’s, thanks mainly to the plays of Jean Giraudoux (1882-1944), the topical rewriting of classical myth and drama became more the rule than the exception on the serious Paris stage, offering edification and entertainment in approximately equal portions. As the Greek writers had shown their inventiveness within rigid constraints of plot, so the French playwrights of the period between World Wars I and II impressed their audiences with thoughtful, often witty variations on the familiar myths that most audience members had studied in school. Jean Anouilh, who came of age as a playwright during the decade of Giraudoux’s prominence, achieved his first major success with Le Voyageur sans bagage (pr., pb. 1937; Traveller Without Luggage, 1959), a dark comedy that, despite its contemporary setting, carries strong references to the Oedipus legend. By the time he addressed himself to Antigone, in the midst of World War II and the Nazi occupation of France, Anouilh had already treated the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice rather successfully on the stage, as he was later to do with that of Jason and Medea. In later years, as French taste moved away from the reworking of classical myth, Anouilh would move in other directions, yet without ever forsaking the characteristic themes of youth and age, and realism and idealism, to be found in Antigone.

Among the more memorable and durable examples of its subgenre, outlasting even the better efforts of Giraudoux, Antigone proved controversial throughout the 1940’s and into the 1950’s because of Anouilh’s ambiguous portrayal of Antigone and Creon. For the initial spectators in 1944, there was little doubt that Antigone represented the indomitable, if weakened, spirit of free France, and Creon the expediency that involved collaboration with the Germans, if need be, in order to keep the country running. It seemed difficult to tell, however, which of the two characters is more sympathetically portrayed. There were those, for example, who saw Antigone’s willful martyrdom as meaningless, outweighed by Creon’s devotion to duty and to the maintenance of order. Such persons...

(The entire section is 890 words.)