Annie John Essay - Critical Evaluation

Jamaica Kincaid

Critical Evaluation

Annie John is the story of a girl who grows up in a small village in Antigua, with a focus on Annie’s relationship with her mother. The plot of the novel is based on author Jamaica Kincaid’s own childhood in Antigua, although Annie John is not an autobiography. The protagonist, Annie John, appears to readers slowly, as if Kincaid is hiding something. Annie’s last name is revealed even later in the novel. This method of revealing names slowly reflects the way children learn important details, over time.

Annie describes each distinct age in her life—organized by Kincaid as one year per chapter—as she advances in the school system, notices changes in her body as she grows, and learns about family, humanity, and life in general. Her learning leads to a loss of innocence, the end of a friendship, a strained relationship with her mother, and other experiences. Annie develops a pattern of meanness toward others, including playmate Sonia, a friend whose mother suddenly dies. Instead of displaying sympathy, Annie reacts to her friend’s mother’s death by refusing to speak with Sonia. This negative, obstinate pattern of behavior continues through the story.

The entire novel takes place in the past, as though Annie is looking back on her youth and remembering short bursts from the time. Because the novel includes no years, months, or dates, the story has a sense of timelessness; the ebb and flow of time runs forward and backward like the tides of the nearby sea. Annie’s age and level of schooling, even the aging of her mother’s hands, are benchmarks of time passing. Those benchmarks are in chronological order.

The novel is interspersed with smaller stories about Annie and her relationships with others, who return to the...

(The entire section is 730 words.)