Criticism > Short Story Criticism > A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens - Natalie Shainess (essay date 1992)
A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens - Natalie Shainess (essay date 1992)
Natalie Shainess (essay date 1992)
SOURCE: “Charles Dickens: The First (Interpersonal) Psychoanalyst or—A Christmas Carol: A Literary Psychoanalysis,” in American Journal of Psychoanalysis, Vol. 52, No. 4, December, 1992, pp. 351–62.
[In the following essay, Shainess maintains that A Christmas Carol “is more than a story or satire—it is a literary psychoanalysis, largely of the interpersonal variety though with a hint of the Freudian as well.”]
Charles Dickens appeared on the British scene in 1812, approximately 300 years after Shakespeare. It may seem to some an exaggeration to connect him with the preeminent writer of all time, William Shakespeare, but I think not. Dickens was primarily a storyteller, not a playwright or poet. But in his understanding of character and society, in the variety, richness, and compelling nature of his storytelling, the comparison holds.
In addition to all his writer's gifts—his...
[The entire page is 5583 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- W. M. Thackeray (review date 1844)
- Edgar Johnson (essay date 1952)
- Robert L. Patten (essay date 1971)
- Elliot L. Gilbert (essay date 1975)
- Michael Patrick Hearn (essay date 1976)
- George Anastaplo (essay date 1978)
- Harry Stone (essay date 1979)
- Stephen Prickett (essay date 1979)
- Martin H. Sable (essay date 1986)
- Paul Davis (essay date 1990)
- Ronald R. Thomas (essay date 1990)
- Paul Davis (essay date 1990)
- Donald R. Burleson (essay date 1992)
- Natalie Shainess (essay date 1992)
- R. D. Butterworth (essay date 1993)
- J. Hillis Miller (essay date 1993)
- Geoffrey Rowell (essay date 1993)
- Audrey Jaffe (essay date 1994)
- Arthur P. Patterson (essay date 1994)
- James R. Simmons, Jr. (essay date 1995)
- Caroline McCracken-Flesher (essay date 1996)
- Lee Erickson (essay date 1997)
- Harry Stone (essay date 1999)
- Fred Guida (essay date 2000)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
