1. Printable Version
2. Download PDF
3. Cite this Page

Raymond Nelson (review date winter 1984)

SOURCE: Nelson, Raymond. “Hills of Home.” Virginia Quarterly Review 60, no. 1 (winter 1984): 169-73.

[In the following review, Nelson explores the defining characteristics of Pancake's short stories.]

Breece David John Pancake was blessed or cursed with the true creative gift. In 1979 he called off his experiment with life, just as he was coming into full possession of his talent. At least for the time being, those facts of biography are likely to dominate responses to his work. The elegiac note has already crept into early reviews of this remarkable first and last book of stories [The Stories of Breece D'J Pancake], and it informs the memorial essays contributed by James Alan McPherson and John Casey to the extent that the fiction, which only yesterday startled Casey with its quality, is left all but unremarked. Probably that is as it should be. There are things that must be said about...

Join eNotes

The above is a free excerpt. Get total access to this content with the:

eNotes Pass

1. Introduction
2. Criticism
   1. Patricia Vigderman (review date 19 March 1983)
   2. Daphne Merkin (review date 9 May 1983)
   3. Raymond Nelson (review date winter 1984)
   4. Paul Hendrickson (review date 10 December 1984)
   5. Ellesa Clay High (essay date fall 1985)
   6. Geoffrey Galt Harpham (essay date summer 1986)
   7. Albert E. Wilhelm (essay date fall 1986)
   8. Cynthia Kadohata (essay date 1989)
   9. David Montrose (review date 23 October 1992)
   10. David Stevens (essay date spring 1996)
   11. Greg Bottoms (essay date September-October 2001)
   12. Susan Salter Reynolds (review date 7 July 2002)
3. Further Reading
4. Copyright