Criticism > Short Story Criticism > Babylon Revisited F. Scott Fitzgerald - Garry N. Murphy and William C. Slattery (essay date 1981)
Babylon Revisited F. Scott Fitzgerald - Garry N. Murphy and William C. Slattery (essay date 1981)
Garry N. Murphy and William C. Slattery (essay date 1981)
SOURCE: "The Flawed Text of 'Babylon Revisited': A Challenge to Editors, a Warning to Readers," in Studies in Short Fiction, Summer, 1981, pp. 315-18.
[In the following essay, Murphy and Slattery argue that a paragraph should be deleted from the "authorized" version of "Babylon Revisited" to reflect Fitzgerald's final intentions for the story.]
No one—not even F. Scott Fitzgerald himself—has ever seen "Babylon Revisited" printed in the final form intended by its author. The reason is astonishingly simple: when the "authorized" version (an extensive revision of the original 1931 Saturday Evening Post story) was printed by Scribners in Taps at Reveille, it contained a monumental editorial error, and, as far as we can determine, that error has been preserved, unremarked, in all subsequent collections and anthologies.
The error occurs early in the...
[The entire page is 1791 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
-
Criticism
- James M. Harrison (essay date 1958)
- John V. Hagopian (essay date 1962)
- Richard R. Griffith (essay date 1963)
- Seymour L. Gross (essay date 1963)
- William R. Osborne (essay date 1964)
- Thomas F. Staley (essay date 1964-65)
- Roy R. Male (essay date 1965)
- Robert I. Edenbaum (essay date 1968)
- David Toor (essay date 1974)
- Rose Adrienne Gallo (essay date 1978)
- James B. Twitchell (essay date 1979)
- Ronald J. Gervais (essay date 1980)
- Garry N. Murphy and William C. Slattery (essay date 1981)
- Elsa Nettels (essay date 1982)
- Carlos Baker (essay date 1982)
- Gene D. Phillips (essay date 1986)
- Joan Turner (essay date 1990)
- Cecil D. Eby (essay date 1995)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
