Criticism > Short Story Criticism > American Naturalism in Short Fiction - George Monteiro (essay date spring 1971)
American Naturalism in Short Fiction - George Monteiro (essay date spring 1971)
George Monteiro (essay date spring 1971)
SOURCE: Monteiro, George. “Society and Nature in Stephen Crane's ‘The Men in the Storm’.” Prairie Schooner 45, no. 1 (spring 1971): 13-17.
[In the following essay, Monteiro views the major thematic concerns of Stephen Crane's “The Men in the Storm” to be violence against man by nature and society.]
Stephen Crane was a philosophical naturalist. This commonplace observation, so dear to the literary and cultural historian, is unfortunately less than accurate. For the truth is that at no time was Crane able to commit himself fully to the implications of the determinism he so much wanted to accept. The difficulty lay in his inability to resolve the conflict between his intellectual commitment to naturalism and his emotional tie to the nineteenth-century Protestantism of his family. If Crane could not embrace his ancestors' Methodism, with its strong emphasis on scriptural authority, neither...
[The entire page is 1792 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Representative Works
- Criticism: Overviews And General Studies
-
Criticism: Major Authors Of American Literary Naturalism
- Warner Berthoff (essay date 1965)
- Stephen Crane
- James Trammel Cox (essay date summer 1957)
- George Monteiro (essay date spring 1971)
- Sydney J. Krause (essay date autumn 1983)
- John J. Conder (essay date 1984)
- Theodore Dreiser
- Yoshinobu Hakutani (essay date 1980)
- Irene Gammel (essay date 1994)
- Jack London
- Earl J. Wilcox (essay date 1983)
- Jeanne Campbell Reesman (essay date winter 1997)
- Frank Norris
- Barbara Hochman (essay date 1988)
- Edith Wharton
- Donna M. Campbell (essay date autumn 1994)
- Scott Emmert (essay date autumn 2002)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
