Warren, Robert Penn - William Logan (review date 2000)
William Logan (review date 2000)
SOURCE: Logan, William. “Robert Penn Warren Collected.” Salmagundi, Nos. 126-27 (Spring-Summer 2000): 298-305.
[In the following review of The Collected Poems of Robert Penn Warren, Logan offers a derisive look at Warren, characterizing him as “a failed major poet.”]
The Collected Poems of Robert Penn Warren preserves in fossilized form some of the poetic movements and anti-movements that flourished in the wake of the moderns. When Warren died ten years ago, heavy with half a century of honors, including three Pulitzer Prizes, he was less a man of letters than an institution of drawling Southern manners and professional gentility. As a young man he had been welcomed into the Fugitives, though membership was often an excuse for writing frowsy, mint-julepy lines like “Who saw, in darkness, how fled / The white eidolon from the fangèd commotion rude?” or stanzas no parodist of...
[The entire page is 2018 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- Cleanth Brooks (essay date 1939)
- E. S. Forgotson (essay date 1941)
- John Crowe Ransom (review date 1944)
- F. O. Matthiessen (review date 1944)
- Dudley Fitts (review date 1944)
- Robert Lowell (review date 1953)
- Babette Deutsch (review date 1953)
- F. Cudworth Flint (review date 1954)
- James Dickey (review date 1958)
- James Wright (review date 1958)
- Louis L. Martz (review date 1969)
- Monroe K. Spears (review date 1970)
- Stephen Yenser (review date 1976)
- J. D. McClatchy (essay date 1977)
- Dave Smith (review date 1979)
- Laurence Lieberman (review date 1981)
- William H. Pritchard (review date 1981)
- Charles Bohner (essay date 1981)
- Monroe K. Spears (essay date 1983)
- Victor Strandberg (essay date 1984)
- James H. Justus (essay date 1984)
- Floyd C. Watkins (essay date 1984)
- Philip Balla (review date 1984)
- Calvin Bedient (essay date 1984)
- Harold Bloom (essay date 1984)
- Harold Bloom (review date 1985)
- Peter Stitt (review date 1985)
- Dave Smith (review date 1985)
- Robert Penn Warren with Peter Stitt (interview date 1985)
- Victor Strandberg (essay date 1986)
- Andrew Zawacki (review date 1999)
- William Logan (review date 2000)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
