Thomas, Edward - Clive Wilmer (essay date March-April 2001)
Clive Wilmer (essay date March-April 2001)
SOURCE: Wilmer, Clive. “Edward Thomas: Englishness and Modernity.” PN Review 138, 27, no. 4 (March-April, 2001): 59-64.
[In the following essay, Wilmer, a poet himself, reads several poems by Thomas to argue that poems such as “Old Man,” “Lob,” and “Fifty Faggots” wrestle with Thomas's complex and sometimes contradictory understanding of Englishness, patriotism, and nostalgia.]
On 1 May 1909, Edward Thomas sent a book he was reviewing to his friend Gordon Bottomley. ‘Here,’ he says in an accompanying letter, ‘is Ezra Pound & I think he has very great things in him & love poems & the “Famam librosque”—in fact nearly all—are extraordinary achievements.’ The following month his review of the book appeared:
Carelessness of sweet sound and of all the old tricks makes Mr Pound's book rather prickly to handle at first … For brusque intensity of effect...
[The entire page is 6530 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- George F. Whicher (essay date April 1920)
- J. Middleton Murry (essay date 1920)
- Theresa Ashton (essay date November-December 1937)
- Cecil Day Lewis (essay date 1954)
- Ralph Lawrence (review date summer 1959)
- Michael Kirkham (essay date summer 1979)
- R. P. Draper (essay date 1985)
- Peter Mitchell (essay date summer 1986)
- Stephen McKenzie (essay date 1990)
- David Bromwich (essay date 1990)
- Edna Longley (essay date 1996)
- Stan Smith (essay date 1999)
- Martin Dodsworth (essay date summer 2000)
- Clive Wilmer (essay date March-April 2001)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
