Sandburg, Carl - The Explicator (essay date 2001)

The Explicator (essay date 2001)

SOURCE: “Sandburg's ‘They Will Say.’” The Explicator 59, no. 3 (2001): 134.

[In the following essay, an anonymous critic discusses the merits of Sandburg's poem “They Will Say.”]

Pity poor Carl Sandburg. Not only is he, at least in Chicago Poems, shamefully driven by ideology (Waggoner 452, 455), but he is guilty of “overly insistent tempos and rigid parallelisms,” “compulsive metrics and rhythms” (Pearce 270, 271), and simultaneously of lacking “meter and verse form, even regular rhythm” (Spiller 180). He “sling[s] a loose, prosy line” (Spayde 108), utters a “blowsy hurrah” (Perkins 42), and is “expostulatory” and “blustering” (Moore 92). Yet at the same time his work is mere “cataloguing” (Walker 126), “mainly a massing of direct details in the fashion of Dreiser” (Spiller 180), and is made up of “flat statements” (Moore 92). And lest we...

[The entire page is 1544 words long]

Join eNotes

The above is a free excerpt. Get total access to this content with the:

eNotes Pass