A Perfect Day for Bananafish

by J. D. Salinger

Have a question? eNotes editors are standing by to help you.

In the story "A Perfect Day for Banana Fish" what is the significance or connection between the "bananafish" and to the story?

studentin...

Student

High School - 11th Grade

Posted by studentinneedofhelp on November 26, 2007 at 7:53 AM and tagged with a perfect day for bananafish, symbolic connection bananafish story, symbolism

Rate this question:

» Flag as inappropriate
Message studentinnee...

Share this question:

4 Answers | add yours

renelane

Teacher

High School - 11th Grade

Editor, Expert, Dickens, The Bard

The banana fish is an imaginary species of fish. According to Seymour, the banana fish is just an average looking fish that is doomed to live a life that ends in tragedy. The previously normal...

(The entire answer is 135 words.)

This is an expert answer, written by an eNotes editor. To read the entire answer, please join eNotes.

Posted by renelane on November 26, 2007 at 8:27 AM

Rate this answer:

» Flag as inappropriate
Message renelane

mastermind2...

Student

College - Sophomore

eNoter

The big picture shows that the bananafish represents societies tendency to focus on material possessions, over-indulge, and waste life and ultimately die from their over-consumption. Reading this story for the first time, I remember I thought for sure there was some sort of sexual symbolism involved here. The whole story about a "banana" fish going into a whole then never being able to leave seemed like a symbol for being whipped. And when the little girl is in the water with Seymore, it is said she throws her head back in pleasure and claims to see a bananafish while Seymore holds her by her feet and pushes her back and forth. The sexual innuendo was too much to ignore.

Posted by mastermind242424 on July 16, 2008 at 1:49 PM

Rate this answer:

» Flag as inappropriate
Message mastermind24...

dirod

eNotes Newbie

To me it represents Seymour itself, the bananafish is an ordinary looking one but with a tragic live, seymour is of that kind, affected strongly and differently by war than ordinary people reacts tragicgly killing himself, the reference of blue denotes calm, its almost a filosophical decition. The references of sexual nature are there as in any human being, but a sensityve nature as the writers one wouldnt give them a role except a satirical one, playing with the references and the posible readings.

Posted by dirod on February 9, 2009 at 11:49 PM

Rate this answer:

» Flag as inappropriate
Message dirod

kristenfusaro

Teacher

High School - 12th Grade

Assistant Editor, Expert, Educator

Seymour Glass is characterized by his peers as someone who is completely out of control; he was released from the military hospital, and no one seems to understand why he was released because of...

(The entire answer is 343 words.)

This is an expert answer, written by an eNotes editor. To read the entire answer, please join eNotes.

Posted by kristenfusaro on July 14, 2010 at 2:16 PM

Rate this answer:

» Flag as inappropriate
Message kristenfusaro

Join for free to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Already a member? Sign in » JOIN eNOTES

Top Tags in A Perfect Day for Bananafish

See all »

Following A Perfect Day for Bananafish

See all »

kristenfusaro

Assistant Editor, Expert, Educator

3,225 points

renelane

Editor, Expert, Dickens, The Bard

24,653 points

mastermind242424

eNoter

92 points

maadhav19

Assistant Editor, Expert

3,019 points

donovan92

eNotes Newbie

60 points