Home > A Passage to India Summary & Study Guide > A Passage to India Group > Discussion Board

i defenetly believe that he is innocent. not because i trust the indians, but because i don't trust the british. I think that adela had been convinced by another British person to accuse Aziz of a horible which he probably didn't commit. i don't know yet if he is guilty or not, but i believe not. i am very exited to find out.

of course he is. Adela is a rotten cowardly liar; who now has her tail stuck in between her legs because she's too scared of looking foolish in front of the English, and succumbs to peer pressure... tell the truth Adela

TELL THE TRUTH.... TELL THE TRUTH..... TELL THE TRUTH

In reply to #1: i definatley think aziz is innocent because he wouldn't have any motive to do such a thing. He is in his own country and he knows the risks when one does such a thing. Most of all we have seen his attitude in the story and he is not the type of person that would do this.

In some ways it does not matter if he is innocent or not as this represents how someone in power, whether it is an individual or a group, can state something and make it so. Aziz is not believed and is not even given a chance to prove himself. He is essentially guilty before proven innocent.

I believe in Aziz. and he was innocent for many reasons;

1- If there is any attempt to do such thing with Adela he will never going to invite Mrs.Moore with here and all of those people who are with them in the trip.

2- Aziz is a muslim man, and what characterises them is not lying. Add to that, that there is no reason to lie.

3- The echo is a symbol, and has the hand in what is happened to Adela.

4- The situation of Adela. When she was scared by something she didn't see. the only thing that she know, is that she has a feeling of scare.

5- Aziz is a kind man, who will never going to hurt who he loves them.

6- The general atmosphere of India also has an effect on Adela and Mrs.Moore.