Home > Other Voices, Other Rooms Summary & Study Guide > Other Voices, Other Rooms Group > Discussion Board

The last paragraph is ambiguous. It states Joel's decision as "clear," but only infers his staying.

At the end of the novel, Joel has become an adult.  He takes responsibility for being the head of the house.  After Randolph nursed him back to health and he returned to the Landing, it is unlikely that Joel would want to leave. Below are two different reasons why Joel probably would not want to leave the Landing.

"The mature Joel ascends from the haunted garden at Skully's Landing to Randolph's room to embrace Randolph, leaving behind both his youth and his own sexual longing."

"Joel decided he liked being dependent. He felt Randolph was the only person who cared for him."

Joel has found what he is looking for, love and acceptance, so why would he leave.

Though Randolf seems to be the best choice for Joel from what he has experience, the relationship between the two can be nothing but dysfunctional. So Randolf never grew up and now needs Joel. At this age, it seems a decision Joel might make, but wrongly. A Joel who had truly matured would have left all these "oddballs," to have his needs fulfilled. I yield, this may be Capote's point, or rationalization, but not a good move for Joel.

Though Randolf seems to be the best choice for Joel from what he has experienced, the relationship between the two can be nothing but dysfunctional. So Randolf never grew up and now needs Joel. At this age, it seems a decision Joel might make, but wrongly. A Joel who had truly matured would have left all these "oddballs," to have his needs fulfilled. I yield, this may be Capote's point, or rationalization, but not a good move for Joel.