The Merchant of Venice Group
Question:
Answers:
-
sagetrieb Teacher
DoctoratePosted by sagetrieb on Monday August 27, 2007 at 4:18 PMThe question is very complex. Shylock asks for "justice" in his demand for the pound of flesh, but Portia (disguised as a lawyer) advises him that mercy is a higher value than justice, and that he should show Antonio mercy. When Shylock refuses, Portia tricks him, telling him he may have only the pound of flesh, no blood, which in effect renders his plea worthless. Thus, Portia holds him to the very strict letter of the law that Shylock asks for: "Thou shalt have justice more than thou desir'st" (4.1.330). She also holds him accountable to another law, that of, as an alien (for Jews were not citizens), threatening the life of an Venetian citizen (4.1.363-370). His punishment, decreed by Antonio, is to convert to Christianity and give up his money (in different ways). To Shakespeare's audience this would be justice (indeed, such a conversion might to that audience save Shylock's soul), but we might think how enormous this sentence is: Shylock loses his religion as well as his livelihood, not to mention his daughter. He has already suffered humiliation for being a Jew, which prompted his behavior to begin with. So, from our point of view, the mitigating circumstances are such that perhaps Antonio could have shown a bit more of the mercy Portia spoke of in her famous speech.
-
dk3006 Teacher
High School - 12th GradePosted by dk3006 on Sunday November 18, 2007 at 3:22 AM
-
sweeto Student
High School - 9th GradePosted by sweeto on Sunday November 18, 2007 at 4:25 AMi dun think so that shylock suffer injustice.he deserves this.everyone hate him coz he lents money with high interest.
-
dathy Student
High School - 9th GradePosted by dathy on Sunday November 18, 2007 at 11:05 AMPersonally I think bankruptcy and Christianity are a bit harsh considering it would only have been equivelent to Assisted suicide if he had killed Antonio.
I mean Antonio agreed to it. It is because he is a Jew that he is punished so severely by the courts.