Criticism > Literary Criticism (1400-1800) > A Modest Proposal, Jonathan Swift - Samuel J. Rogal (essay date April 1968)
A Modest Proposal, Jonathan Swift - Samuel J. Rogal (essay date April 1968)
Samuel J. Rogal (essay date April 1968)
SOURCE: Rogal, Samuel J. “The Timelessness of A Modest Proposal.” English Record 18, no. 4 (April 1968): 48-53.
[Rogal observes in the following essay that A Modest Proposal has endured as a work of consequence because its rhetorical composition overshadows its outdated subject matter.]
Ricardo Quintana labels A Modest Proposal as the “greatest of all the later writings on Ireland and his [Swift's] last prose masterpiece. …”1 Apparently he is at least equating the quality of the 1729 essay with the earlier, more developed, and better known Tale of a Tub, Battle of the Books (both 1704), and Gulliver's Travels (1726). Why would a Swift scholar preface his discussion of A Modest Proposal by referring to it as a “great prose masterpiece”? The answers are not only clear, but important to the discussion of the essay as being timeless....
[The entire page is 2792 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- George Wittkowsky (essay date January-October 1943)
- Maurice Johnson (essay date May 1958)
- Oliver W. Ferguson (essay date October 1959)
- Louis A. Landa (essay date 1959)
- Charles Allen Beaumont (essay date fall 1960)
- Edward W. Rosenheim, Jr. (essay date 1963)
- John W. Tilton (essay date 1966)
- Samuel J. Rogal (essay date April 1968)
- Samuel L. Macey (essay date 10 November 1968)
- Denis Donoghue (essay date 1969)
- Thomas Lockwood (essay date summer 1974)
- Wayne C. Booth (essay date 1974)
- Robert F. Willson Jr. (essay date autumn 1976)
- C. N. Manlove (essay date 1978)
- C. J. Rawson (essay date 1978)
- Robert Hunting (essay date 1989)
- Lloyd Davis (essay date May 1992)
- Robert Phiddian (essay date summer 1996)
- Robert Mahoney (essay date 1998)
- John Richardson (essay date October 2001)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
