Why does Dickens change feelings toward the peasants throughout the novel?

1 Answer | Add Yours

mwestwood's profile pic

mwestwood | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

Ruth Glancy, Canadian professor and  authority on A Tale of Two Cities, contends that Charles Dickens takes a Romantic attitude toward history.  Influenced by his reading of Thomas Carlyle's History of the French Revolution, Dickens romantically personified the causes of the revolution as Hunger and the Farmer and the Mender of Roads; he perceives the conditions of hunger and oppression as the main causes for the revolution of the peasants against the aristocracy of France. Towards these oppressed peasants, Dickens is sympathetic.  However, once the revolution begins, the bloodlust and desire for revenge, personified as the Vengeance, become obssessive and excessive. 

This contrast between the peasants as they are earlier in the novel is exemplfied by such characters as Ernest Defarge and even Gaspard.  M. Defarge, former servant of Dr. Manette, sympathizes with the physician's imprisonment in the Bastille and is yet loyal to him.  He pleads with his wife to spare the lives of Charles Darnay, ne Evremonde, and his family.  After the spy John Basard departs their shop, Defarge says to his wife,

"But it is very strange...that, after all our sympathy for Monsieur her [Lucie's] father and herself, her husband's name should be proscribed under your hand at this moment, by the side of that infernal dog's who has just left us?"

However, Madame Defarge is bloodthirsty in her desire for revenge against the Evremonde's, for she wants the entire family eradicated:

"Stranger things than that will happen when it does come...I have them both here, of a certainty; and they are both her for their merits; that is enough."

Also in contrast to Madame Defarge is the father whose child is run over by the carriage of the Marquis d'Evremonde, Gaspard, who seeks revenge, but his is only against the murderer, the Marquis, and not the entire family.  But Madame Defarge becomes maniacal in her lust for blood and revenge, rushing to kill Lucie before her husband can save her and her child.  Like the Vengeance, Madame Defarge desires the death of all aristocrats and anyone connected to them, such as the poor seamstress who innocently goes to her death. 

Thus, it may be that while Dickens sympathizes with the peasants who revolt against oppression, he does not approve of those who indiscrimately slaughter anyone that they decide is their enemy, acting much as those who dominated during the Reign of Terror.


We’ve answered 317,777 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question