Homework Help

Which is the best English novel? Since it is a matter of opinion, I am offering the...

billdelaney's profile pic

Posted via web

dislike 3 like

Which is the best English novel?

Since it is a matter of opinion, I am offering the question for general discussion. My personal opinion is that the best English novel--that is, the best novel written by an English author--is Great Expectations--by Charles Dickens. But I am sure there must be a wide range of opinions. I am also wondering whether amit97 means the best English novel or the best novel in English, which would include James Joyce's Ulysses  and a lot of American novels. I might vote for The Ambassadors  by Henry James if he were in the running.

35 Answers | Add Yours

lentzk's profile pic

Posted (Answer #2)

dislike 1 like

I agree with post #1, Great Expectations by Charles Dickens, is phenomenal in so many ways, and a classic example of English literature.

But... I would counter this with my all-time favorite English novel, Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen.  With all of its social commentary on social class, love, marriage, and women's roles, Pride and Prejudice is a stand-out contribution to English literature.  It is brilliantly written and enjoyable to read (and re-read!).

loraaa's profile pic

Posted (Answer #3)

dislike 1 like

For me,,,,I love,,,,,,,,"Pride and Prejudice" is a novel by Jane Austen,This is story "deals with issues of manners,morality, education, upbringing...etc"  ^_^

speamerfam's profile pic

Posted (Answer #4)

dislike 1 like

My vote would be for Great Expectations as well, if we are speaking about novels written by people who are English.  However, if we are speaking of novels written in English, my vote would be tied for The Great Gatsby and Huckleberry Finn.  What a difficult decision! 

mwestwood's profile pic

Posted (Answer #5)

dislike 1 like

This is such a difficult choice as it is unfair to evaluate novels against one another when they are from different social periods since authors are so much a part of their era. 

Indeed, Charles Dickens is at the top of my list of profoundly influential and artistic English authors. But, Thomas Hardy's Tess of d'Ubervilles is an absolutely wonderful and darkly pensive narrative that certainly challenged his era.  His originality of thought and poignant perspective is amazing. And, his style of writing is superior to the didacticism of Dickens.  For, Hardy is ever the poet even when he writes prose. ( It is a shame that he was so criticized that he retreated from prose.)  

Writer and critic Albert Guerard writes of Tess of the d'Ubervilles,

Hardy the novelist is a major transitional figure between the popular moralists and popular entertainer of Victorian fiction and the serious, visionary, often symbolizing novelists of today.

e-martin's profile pic

Posted (Answer #6)

dislike 1 like

Personally, I'd give my vote to Heart of Darknessbecause I find it to be enigmatic, engaging, re-readable, poetic, and timeless. The social trappings of the work of Dickens, Austen, and even Woolf are not part of Conrad's masterpiece. This stark little work is a testament to man's most profoundly individual impulses.

lmetcalf's profile pic

Posted (Answer #7)

dislike 1 like

I too would have to say Pride and Prejudice but my mind also went to Wuthering Heights for its darker themes and characterizations -- it is arguably a more "sophisticated" work and more clearly a novel reflective of its Romantic time period.

rrteacher's profile pic

Posted (Answer #8)

dislike 1 like

I agree with the choice of Heart of Darkness. Few authors have ever crammed so much meanings into such a relatively short novel. Also, few authors have been so successful at creating and maintaining a mood, while simultaneously loading it with so much meaning. It is a brilliant novel. For best English language, I would go with The Sound and the Fury. 

sanukriti59's profile pic

Posted (Answer #9)

dislike 1 like

Mrs. Dalloway by Woolf for the writing technique. D.H. Lawrence's 'Sons and Lovers' is also a good one. 'Heart of Darkness' can also be counted though I am a bit not in favor of the way women are represented by Conrad.

bullgatortail's profile pic

Posted (Answer #10)

dislike 1 like

I'd have to go with Dickens' Great Expectations and Conrad's Heart of Darkness. Great Expectations will always be able to stand on its own because of the great story line, characters and Dickens' way with words. Conrad's story is also one that defies time, evidenced by its adaptation to film in Apocalypse Now.

volleyball96's profile pic

Posted (Answer #11)

dislike 1 like

Becasue of it's writting style, Pride and Prejudice!

ognesperanza's profile pic

Posted (Answer #12)

dislike 1 like

For my money I would say that Sherlock Holmes consitutes one of the greatest characters of all time and as such his first appearance - A Study in Scarlet, constitutes the greatest novel.  I wont say that it is perfect, nor will I content that the plot was particuarly original but the mode of exploration and character are so engaging. 

The impact of A.C.D's beloved character of Holmes, the man in the ubiquitous deerstalker cap has been vast! He arguably birthed the modern detective novel and half of the TV shows, movies and novels since its creation owe their construction to it.  Even now the love of the person of Holmes and his brand of mystery still captivates audiences - From Patricia Cornwall, to Castle, House, CSI and Robert Downey Jr and Benedict Cumberbatch the character and plots of Sherlock Holmes are as effective now as they were at the time of publication. 

As a fan of Holmes I am jealous of those who have never read any of the texts before, it means that you are approaching a reading of Holmes for the first time.  While the stories can be read over and over for their characterisation and dialogue only once will you get to truly experience the case as it unfurls, notice as Holmes notices, be fascinated when Watson is fascinated, or as was my experience, stand with Lestrad and be utterly confused until Holmes deigns to enlighten you!  

florine's profile pic

Posted (Answer #13)

dislike 1 like

     I find it difficult to opt for only one single novel. I'd rather select thecomplete works of one single writer, a major writer like Dickens as regards 19th century literature. But together with Virginia Woolf, the most influential 20 th century writer with "best English language" is probably Irish: I mean Joyce's Ulysses or Finnegans Wake as a literary experiment on language.

   

becca1457's profile pic

Posted (Answer #14)

dislike 1 like

Pride & prejudice !!!

overworked's profile pic

Posted (Answer #15)

dislike 1 like

I really loved Mark Twain's "The adventures of Huckleberry Finn", it was the first novel I read that contained colloquial language. It was a lot of fun for me when i was eleven years old.

renoa's profile pic

Posted (Answer #16)

dislike 1 like

I lovePride & prejudice

manjusree's profile pic

Posted (Answer #17)

dislike 1 like

The best English Novel so far is Wuthering Heights... with a intense depiction of characters and an equally brooding, fierce moorish setting, it is indeed a book to cherish.. As the setting is, so is the love of the protogonist Heathcliff.

Havent found any book  that can beat that... I would also vouch for another of my favourite writer, Thomas Hardy.... absolutely brilliant in his portrayal of troubled characters, his stories tell us that Man has nothing to do but merely act according to his Fate.

mstultz72's profile pic

Posted (Answer #18)

dislike 1 like

According to William S. Burt's The Novel 100: A Ranking of the Greatest Novels of All-Time, the greatest English novel is Joyce's Ulysses (#3).  (see http://www.adherents.com/people/100_novel.html)

The Observer listed its greatest as Pilgrims Progress (#2) and Robinson Crusoe (#3), "the first English novel."

A composite list of Authors' Favorite Works ranks Middlemarch (#11) and Great Expectations (#13)

Modern Library lists Ulysses (#1) and Portrait of an Artist as a Young Man (#3) as their modern classics.  

For me, it's got to be 1984.  One professor I've heard say that the 20th Century will be remembered for its cruelty and inhumanity, and no other novel captures that better than 1984.  It's beautifully and painfully written, translates so well to the 21st Century, appeals to mass audiences, and plays as comedy and tragedy.  

msnewbooklover's profile pic

Posted (Answer #19)

dislike 1 like

i will say Wuthering Height as the best novel for its plot,good vs evil,power of love,strong characters and all...and great expectation too for its best narrative style and a moving story...

mian-j's profile pic

Posted (Answer #20)

dislike 1 like

Trully all the above mentioned are one of a kind, especially Great Expectations, but don't you think Frankenstein by Mary Shelly should also be considered as it has such effect on the mind to make people wonder about their conscience?

fkiani's profile pic

Posted (Answer #21)

dislike 1 like

I love Hemingway's style of writing.

rhettbutler's profile pic

Posted (Answer #23)

dislike 1 like

Though it has never been an easy thing to give one novel the label of being best....i think all the novels have their own charm and sensibility around them. some have their classic touch that is making them a class apart. 

still if i have to make my choice about one best novel then i would like to go for July's People written by Nadine Gordimer. The novel delineates the imagined future of South Africa liberated from the clutches of dehumanizing and segregationist polcy called Apartheid. 

How the characteras are developing alongwith the plot and it has always been amazing for me to see them struggling with their past positions determined by their colour.

Although the novel is most of the times has been labelled as the work that is not easy to follow because of the hazardous narrative technique of Gordimer...but i think her way of writing is quite appropriate for the handling of sch themes.

mimerajver's profile pic

Posted (Answer #24)

dislike 1 like

Sometimes we feel bound to answer a question in the very terms it has been formulated without deciding first whether the question itself poses a formulation problem. This is what I would call "a poorly defined question."

I find that any direct answer to "the best English novel" implies a subjective choice that automatically strikes off a very large number of outstanding works. The English novel has a long tradition and evolution. We cannot compare 19th century English novels to experimental, early 20th century works, mid-20th century postmodernism, or late 20th century political thrillers. I find it as irrational as comparing oranges and chairs.

Following the changes to the canon of the novel, shouldn't we first reduce the scope of the question and then answer accordingly, justifying our choice?

I agree that Great Expectations is probably the best 19th century novel, but find no valid standards to compare it to, for example, Mrs. Dalloway, nor can I compare either of them to John Fowles's The Magus

I'd love some feedback on the above.

btlit13's profile pic

Posted (Answer #25)

dislike 1 like

Taking this from the perspective of a book that is typically read in a Middle or High school level English (ELA) class, I would have to pick either The Crucible or To Kill a Mockingbird. I feel like both of those books are accessable to students at different levels of instruction and both can be applied to modern themes, which means that students can connect to them. I find that it's hard for students to connect to most of the books in the 'cannon.' Also, they are just really good reads :)

1 Reply | Hide Replies

billdelaney's profile pic

Posted (Reply #1)

dislike 1 like

But the person who originally asked the question specified the best English novel. I take that to mean the best novel by an English writer, and not the best novel written in the English language. The Crucible is a play, and both The Crucible and To Kill a Mockingbird are by Americans.

angel-girl's profile pic

Posted (Answer #26)

dislike 1 like

"The Chrysalids" by John Wyndham is great! It shows how the earth will die in the future and the fatal consequences of nuclear radioactivity. A must read!!

kplhardison's profile pic

Posted (Answer #28)

dislike 1 like

Sometimes we feel bound to answer a question in the very terms it has been formulated without deciding first whether the question itself poses a formulation problem. This is what I would call "a poorly defined question."

I find that any direct answer to "the best English novel" implies a subjective choice that automatically strikes off a very large number of outstanding works. The English novel has a long tradition and evolution. We cannot compare 19th century English novels to experimental, early 20th century works, mid-20th century postmodernism, or late 20th century political thrillers. I find it as irrational as comparing oranges and chairs.

Following the changes to the canon of the novel, shouldn't we first reduce the scope of the question and then answer accordingly, justifying our choice?

I agree that Great Expectations is probably the best 19th century novel, but find no valid standards to compare it to, for example, Mrs. Dalloway, nor can I compare either of them to John Fowles's The Magus

I'd love some feedback on the above.

Well, then, and "best" is further complicated by the question of the literary definition of "best": story? crafting? mastery of English? enjoyment, moral quality, psychological effect, social value, all of the above, some of the above, definitely notsome of the above? Defining what is good in literature is very complicated and, it seems to me, the current definition(s) is vague, ambiguous, and perhaps too all-inclusive. For instance, the more I analyze Hemingway's works, the more I recognize him as a great writer, though I still decline to read anymore of his books because I don't like the psychological effect they produce. The end result is that the only answer that can be given to "the best English novel" must be derived from "in your opinion" and "based on your criterion." For instance, I say Spenser's Epithalamion is the best English poetry, ever, based on all of the above; and I say Austen's Pride and Prejudice is the best English novel based on all of the above and because I can read it year after year without being bored stiff by the language. But, who agrees with me? Not too many, I think. [That was fun.]

kellyleastmead's profile pic

Posted (Answer #30)

dislike 1 like

I agree that Dickens' works framed the Vistorian Era. Yet, Frankenstein stands out in my top three, along with Jane Erye. The romantic, gothic, and alleghorical richnesses still are as fresh and fascinating as they were when the book came out (from what I've read:-) I wasn't around then;-)

salimj's profile pic

Posted (Answer #31)

dislike 1 like

I would say Pride and Prejudice is the best at least my best.

zeynep12345's profile pic

Posted (Answer #32)

dislike 1 like

the 39 clues is an interesting book, i used to read it all the time when i was young! Yes and i agree with the first post , I am truly a charles Dickens fan

shehzaadi's profile pic

Posted (Answer #33)

dislike 1 like

My personal opinion is that this is quite unfair to judge novels or any literary composition against one another because each and every writer belonge to a different era and has a different state of mind... I can add my three most favourite novels here;Pride and Prejudice, A Tale of Two Cities, Jazz.

cheerfulgal's profile pic

Posted (Answer #34)

dislike 1 like

according to me, novels by ravinder singh and chetan bhagat are jst superb.....howevr, u cn also try sudha murthy's novels.........they r also gud.... for eg: gently falls the bakula, mahasweta, etc are soms of her novels which are worth reading....

georgiegirl10's profile pic

Posted (Answer #35)

dislike 1 like

Although Great Expectations is undoubtably one of the best novels in the English canon, I'm surprised that some of Dickens' other works don't get a mention. A Tale of Two Cities and Oliver Twist for example. Jane Eyre, Pride and Predjudice, Middlemarch and Vanity Fair have also been very influential in the development of the English novel as well as being superbly written novels with really strong and memorable characters. I wish I could include some of the great Irish writers like Swift and Wilde.

amitsingh11582's profile pic

Posted (Answer #36)

dislike 1 like

The question is really very difficult to answer at once because it depends upon the mood, nature, personality and taste of person. So it differs from person to person.

one who likes light things cant love tough and vice versa. "Best English Novel" undoubtedly gives a platform for discussion but no one can give an universal and general name. It is like which is the best place in the world..... answer will sure differ.

But individually I being Indian like indian novels written in english like "Guide" of R. K. Narayanan. Well, I am not denying the sublimity of "Pride and Prejudice" and other english novels.

 

aimal's profile pic

Posted (Answer #37)

dislike 1 like

typical discussion but i do rate to wuthering height and sond and fury because of its narrative techniques .

 

udonbutterfly's profile pic

Posted (Answer #38)

dislike 1 like

I am a big fan of classic romantic novels. So books (books by English writers) like Wuthering Heights, Pride and Prejudice, and Sense and Sensibility tops the cake for me. But if we are talking about books that are written in English some of my favorites would have to be Ethan Frome, and Catch-22. All the plots are so well delivered and executed I love it!. Once you get past certain Vernacular reading becomes much easier and themes and symbolism become more easy to spot.

bulbanandi's profile pic

Posted (Answer #22)

dislike 0 like

twilight 

 

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes