Homework Help

In 1984, when Winston said to Julia, "You're only a rebel from the waist downwards,"...

lulubear327's profile pic

Posted via web

dislike 2 like

In 1984, when Winston said to Julia, "You're only a rebel from the waist downwards," what did he mean?

 

2 Answers | Add Yours

missy575's profile pic

Posted (Answer #1)

dislike 1 like

Winston is insinuating that Julia is only capable of rebelling with her body, not her heart or mind. Winston enjoys the rebellion of her body because it is in the act of sex that she primarily rebels. However, as Winston tries to encourage Julia to think about Goldstein's book or to think about the possibility of joining the Brotherhood, her only interest in it is to satisfy him. Ideologically, she is not old enough to remember what the world was like before the hostile dictatorship of the alleged Big Brother.

Winston becomes more human throughout the majority of Book 2. This is due, in large part, to Julia. He is experiencing a relationship that he failed to ever have before. This comment comes as a result of Winston longing for the next piece of human intimacy: companionship. Winston longs for someone who will think similarly and be capable of discussion about the conditions of the world they live in.

Julia has been a rebel with her body with scores of men. She goes to meetings with the Anti-Sex League just to throw off the Thought Police.

Sources:

gpane's profile pic

Posted (Answer #2)

dislike 0 like

As the previous answer states, this is a reference to the essentially physical nature of Julia's rebellion. Unlike Winston, whose rebellion is ideological and intellectual, Julia defies the Party chiefly because it denies her the physical pleasures that she so craves. The most obvious way in which she does this is by engaging in the act of sex. She tells Winston she's had several lovers in the past - and appears distinctly unmoved by the fate of at least one of them, a Party member who committed suicide before he could be eliminated by the Party. "A good thing too," is her response, "otherwise they'd have had my name out of him when he confessed." She appears distinctly cold here, although she does show genuine warmth towards Winston.

Julia also wants other physical indulgences, like make-up and chocolate. She wants to blossom out into a woman in the way that the Party denies; therefore when she takes off the shapeless sash of the Junior Anti-Sex League to which she ironically belongs, this is highly symbolic. She really wants the finer and sweeter things in life, which the Party is so dead set against. Her physical needs and desires orchestrate her rebellion. 

Sources:

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes