Better Students Ask More Questions.
What is the the theme of the story "Dusk" by Saki (H. H. Munro)?Please explain the...
3 Answers | add yours
Dusk" is another one of Saki's darkly ironic tales. The protagonist, Gortsby, spends the duration of the story observing people scurrying about at dusk. He thinks of most of the people whom he watches as being defeated and believes that dusk represents the time of defeat for humans. The story features third person limited point of view, so most of the characterization of Gortsby occurs through Saki's writing down Gortsby's thoughts. The character possesses a cynical view of the human state and has experienced some type of defeat of his own--Saki never details what that failure is on Gortsby's part; he simply writes that it is not a financial failure.
The first passerby whom Gortsby observes is an older man who seems dejected and reluctant to go home. The protagonist thinks that he most likely receives no respect at home or that he goes home to a place that he can barely afford to keep. Shortly after Gortsby's observation begins, the old man gets up from the bench and walks away.
The second "victim" of Gortsby's cynicism is a young man who is better dressed than the first and who makes a show of being very upset. Gortsby initiates a conversation, and the young man tells him that he has forgotten the name of the hotel at which he is supposed to be staying and that he has no money on him. He left his hotel room to get a bar of soap and a drink and cannot find his way back to his lodgings. Gortsby is skeptical about the young man's integrity and mentions that he has a good story but that he failed to produce proof of his predicament--a bar of soap. The young man realizes that his con has failed and flees the scene.
Gortsby prepares to sit back and gloat over his wise judgment of human nature when he spots a wrapped bar of soap near the park bench. He thinks that he has misjudged the young man, runs after him, apologizes for disbelieving him, and gives him money. Gortsby walks back to his bench, slightly chagrined. Moments later, the first old man returns to the bench and tells Gortsby that he is looking for his bar of soap.
Saki ironically leaves the reader with the lesson that one should not be too confident in his or her view of the human character
Posted by harshitagrawal on June 8, 2011 at 7:54 PM (Answer #1)
tuchi aai padli , matke aali
Posted by tj98 on September 5, 2012 at 11:39 AM (Answer #2)
To me, the main theme of this story is that people are not able to really know what is in the hearts of the other people that they meet. I think that this is why the story is entitled "Dusk" -- because people see other people as if it is dusk. The others' motives are only seen in dim light and we cannot be sure of what they are.
This ties in to the idea of deception. In this story, the young man deceives Gortsby. He is able to do this because Gortsby (like all people) cannot see into the hearts of other people. Gortsby is not suspicious enough of the young man and so he is fooled when he finds the bar of soap.
So a theme of the story is deception -- Gortsby can be deceived because he, like all people, lives in a kind of dusk when it comes to reading other people's motives.
Posted by pohnpei397 on July 8, 2010 at 1:42 PM (Answer #3)
Related QuestionsSee all »
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.