What made the Vietnam war different from others in US history?

2 Answers | Add Yours

docholl1's profile pic

Stephen Holliday | College Teacher | (Level 1) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The U. S. failed to recognize that the Vietnam was a civil war, and most of the wars in which we engaged--most notably WWI and WWII--were wars based on one country's domination over another.

Ostensibly, we fought the Vietnam War to keep the southern part of the country--tenuously democratic (but with rigged elections)--from becoming part of the communist north.  At the time, the U. S. had a treaty obligation under SEATO (Southeast Asia Treaty Organization) to help the South Vietnamese, and our assistance was "requested" under SEATO.  In addition, when we believed that the North Vietnamese fired on U. S. ships in internation waters, we believed we had justification for increased military involvement.

As our experience in Vietnam unfolded, it became obvious to many in the United States--both military and civilian--that we were in the middle of a civil war between the North and South Vietnam.  No matter how many troops we sent to Vietnam, our enemies were willing to fight and die to expel us no matter how long it took .

Another aspect that was unique to this war is that we generally did not take, occupy, and control land--our strategy was to kill the enemy.  We did not ever have sufficient troops in country to occupy substantial parts of the country.   Most wars in which we have been successful were won by taking and occupying land until the enemy has no room to hide.  In Vietnam, we ignored this fundamental rule, and this helped eventually to insure our departure from Vietnam and the success of the North, which won the war by taking and holding territory until it had conquered South Vietnam.


pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The Vietnam War was different than any other war that the United States had fought to that point.  This was largely because it was not mainly a war between armies.  The major enemy for the US was more of a guerrilla organization that did not fight traditional battles.  This was also different than other US wars because it was not a war to take  territory.  The US was fighting in a friendly country, trying to destroy an insurgency.  This was very different from wars like WWII where the US was invading areas held by hostile forces.  These were the two most important differences between this war and all other wars that the US had fought.


We’ve answered 317,963 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question