Homework Help

According to Thoreau, what is the flaw in majority rule?

user profile pic

althia-daly | eNotes Newbie

Posted February 26, 2009 at 8:59 AM via web

dislike 2 like

According to Thoreau, what is the flaw in majority rule?

2 Answers | Add Yours

user profile pic

dneshan | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Associate Educator

Posted February 27, 2009 at 10:10 AM (Answer #1)

dislike 3 like

According to Thoreau in “Civil Disobedience”, the flaw in majority rule is just that – the government is ruled by the majority and the minority is left out.  Thoreau states,

     “But government in which the majority rule in all cases can not  be based on justice, even as far as men understand it.”

 

By this, he means that it does not serve all people if it is only one group, no matter how large a group, who decides what is best for all.  Thoreau continues the essay by saying that people should be allowed to govern themselves and should know the difference between right and wrong and adhere to that without being overruled by the “majority”.

user profile pic

kipling2448 | (Level 2) Educator Emeritus

Posted December 8, 2014 at 8:35 PM (Answer #2)

dislike 0 like

In his essay Civil Disobedience, Henry David Thoreau was ambivalent regarding the attributes of majority rule, recognizing in an unregulated political environment that it was no guarantor of justice.  Hardly original in these concerns – the Framers of the U.S. Constitution fully understood the moral and practical necessities of ensuring minority (in a political if not ethnic sense) rights were respected – he was nevertheless an articulate advocate against over-reliance on the will of absolute majorities in determining public policy.  As he wrote in this seminal essay:

“After all, the practical reason why, when the power is once in the hands of the people, a majority are permitted, and for a long period continue, to rule is not because they are most likely to be in the right, nor because this seems fairest to the minority, but because they are physically the strongest. But a government in which the majority rule in all cases cannot be based on justice, even as far as men understand it.”

Majority rule is an essential characteristic of democratic government, but is not in and of itself a guarantor of democratic tradition.  Thoreau recognized this when he asked rhetorically,

“Unjust laws exist: shall we be content to obey them, or shall we endeavor to amend them, and obey them until we have succeeded, or shall we transgress them at once?”

With the expression of such sentiments, Thoreau place himself squarely within the democratic tradition envisioned by James Madison and others who feared tyranny of a majority.

Sources:

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes