I imagin that she was smileing. I don't see why she wouldn't. The painter would of painted the real picture.
3 Answers | Add Yours
Your question makes me think of Nat King Cole singing "Mona Lisa."
Since the painting's rise in popularity, especially after Walter Pater's essay in 1867, many people have debated about her enigmatic smile. Not much is historically known about the original subject of the painting, Lisa del Giacondo, and even less is known about da Vinci's artistic decision making when creating the painting. The speculation just adds to the mystery.
I think it is perfectly possible for a painter to use a model and then change the painting based on what he or she wanted. Leonardo da Vinci might well have decided to add the smile later. It is up to the artist. Art is not about creating an exact replica.
I was told by a teacher a while back that Mona Lisa wasn't a real person and that it may have been Leonardo da Vinci himself. The teacher also said that da Vinci painted himself as a woman smiling because he knew something we didn't (which is that the Mona Lisa was actually Leonadro himself. But I'm not possitive that this information is true.
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.Join eNotes