In this short play, what is the conflict between men and women?

2 Answers | Add Yours

akannan's profile pic

Ashley Kannan | Middle School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The conflicts that Glaspell displays in her play exist on both the social level and the personal one.  In the latter, the difficulties of the Hale marriage can be seen as a display of gender conflicts.  The man is overtly controlling and seeks to silence his wife's voice, a demonstration of a gender conflict.  In her mind, she has no other recourse than to murder him.  Outside of this, the political or social level of gender challenges exist with the investigation of the crime.  The detectives investigating the crime are male and they dismiss the ideas the women put forth, and dispel the notion that they could solve the crime.  The men's analysis of what happens is not close to being accurate in comparison to the women, who talk and "hash out" what happened through discourse.  This can not only reveal a difference between how men and women perceive consciousness, but represents a conflict when the former dismisses the attempts of the latter.

mstultz72's profile pic

mstultz72 | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Gender differences are crucial to understanding Trifles.  Mrs. Hale killed her husband because he had cut her off from her community and trapped her in a domestic servant role as his wife.

In investigating the homicide, the men (sheriff, the local prosecutor, and a neighboring farmer) are condescending, linear-thinking, and only see the world through male eyes: they take the feminine domestic role entirely for granted.

Meanwhile, the women in the kitchen piece together the motive from the subtle clues left behind by Mrs. Hale in her kitchen.  Whereas the males are report-talkers (focus on facts, information that establish status), the women are rapport-talkers (focus on intimate details that build relationships).

So says Enotes:

In simple terms, Trifles suggests that men tend to be aggressive, brash, rough, analytical and selfcentered; in contrast, women are more circumspect, deliberative, intuitive, and sensitive to the needs of others. It is these differences that allows Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale to find the clues needed to solve the crime, while their husbands miss the same clues.

Meanwhile the women, perhaps sensing the gloom and terror in the house, enter timidly and stand close to each other just inside the door. They are partly identified by the roles their husbands play. An important detail is they are always referred to by their married names only, and no first names are used.

We’ve answered 317,614 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question