Is this sentence punctuated correctly?
The wanderer found no reason to be wary of him, but nonetheless the proud old man replied, “No need, I am quite all right,” as he plodded forward through the street.
3 Answers | Add Yours
The sentence is “correct” as given, but there are some variations that might be stronger. First, [need, I am… ] could be [need; I am..] because the implied “There is” makes it two coordinate clauses [There is no need;] and [I am quite all right] that can be best separated by a semicolon. Also there is some question about the necessity for a comma before the quotation. Finally, the punctuation at the end of the quotation could be an exclamation mark [!] and it would be inside the quotation as part of the utterance. So a somewhat smoother solution would be:
The wanderer found no reason to be wary of him, but nonetheless the proud old man replied “No need; I am quite all right!” as he plodded forward through the street.
I would place a comma after word "nonetheless," since a definite pause would help the reading of the sentence. Otherwise, the sentence looks good as far as punctuation.
Looks good. I would add a comma after "nonetheless." This is a preference.
We’ve answered 288,006 questions. We can answer yours, too.Ask a question