Better Students Ask More Questions.
Is this sentence gramatically correct? It is Bob and she who everyone wants to hear.
1 Answer | add yours
- Determine the predicate of the relative clause. The action word(s) is/are the verbs that act as the predicate(s) of the clause. In this case, the verb wants is the predicate.
- Ask "Who + wants?"
- Since the answer is everyone, then everyone is the real subject, not the Nominative Case pronoun, who.
- So, since the role of subject has already been filled, the Nominative Case relative pronoun cannot be used. Instead, the Objective Case must be written (whom).
No. Grammatically, "who" is incorrect. Because everyone is actually the subject of the relative clause--everyone is the subject of the predicate wants--the relative pronoun should be whom, objective case, since it is the direct object of the predicate hear.
The method to use to determine which word is the subject of a relative clause and whether, then, to use who or whom is as follows:
To make this sentence correct, therefore, write,
It is Bob and she whom everyone wants to hear.
*Note that she is correct in the compound Predicate Nominative after "is."
*It must also be noted that the use of passive voice is not recommended for most writing. ("It is Bob and she"). So if revision of the sentence is permitted, the student can rewrite the sentence as follows:
Bob and she are the speakers whom everyone wants to hear.
Posted by mwestwood on August 26, 2013 at 2:35 AM (Answer #1)
Related QuestionsSee all »
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.