Homework Help

That's exactly what he said about (you, me, yours).In the sentence above, the word...

user profile pic

sanjiwan | Student, Undergraduate | Honors

Posted April 20, 2010 at 8:13 AM via web

dislike 1 like

That's exactly what he said about (you, me, yours).

In the sentence above, the word "you" in parentheses is the correct answer. Can anyone explain why it is so? Why is "me" not correct?

2 Answers | Add Yours

user profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted April 20, 2010 at 8:16 AM (Answer #1)

dislike 1 like

There must be something else that is going on here -- something else that you are supposed to consider when answering this question.

I say this because if you are just talking about grammar, both "you" and "me" are perfectly grammatically correct.  So I wonder if there was some other part to this question.

For example, did this question perhaps refer back to some other question or to some other passage?  Maybe in that other passage, it was clear that "he" was talking about "you" and not about "me."

If not, I see no reason why "that's exactly what he said about me" would not be perfectly correct.

Now that I think about it, that must be the case, because even "yours" would be fine.  You said his mobile phone was no good?  That's exactly what he said about yours."

user profile pic

Karen P.L. Hardison | College Teacher | eNotes Employee

Posted April 23, 2010 at 4:04 AM (Answer #2)

dislike 1 like

In this sentence, "That" is a demonstrative pronoun in the Subject slot. The apostrophe s is a contracted form of "that is" in which "is" is the be verb filling the Verb slot in the matrix sentence. The adverb "exactly" is the adverbial complement to the be verb (is).

The matrix Object slot is filled by the wh-clause "what he said...." In the wh-clause, "he" is the Subject of the subordinate clause embedded in the matrix clause and "said" is the Verb. The prepositional phrase "about you/me/yours" fills the wh-clause Object slot as an Indirect Object.

Starting with "yours": "Yours" is the possessive form of second person pronoun "you" and as such can be used in a Subject or Object slot. So if you wished, you could say "...he said about yours," with "about" being the preposition in a Prepositional Phrase filling the Object slot as an Indirect Object.

Contrast this to first person "I" and "me" in which "I" is the Subject form and must be used in the Subject slot, while "me" is the Object form and must be used in the Object slot. Since "me" is the first person Object form, it can certainly be used in an Object slot in an Indirect Object: "...he said about me." Finally, "you" is the same in Subject and Object use, so saying "...he said about you," with "you" as part of the Indirect Object in the Object slot is also correct.

The only reason one might prefer "you" over "me" or "yours" is that in previous usage, which is no longer popular, it was thought impolite to talk about yourself, hence the origin of excusing phrases like "if I do say so myself...." Similarly, it was once considered impolite to talk about someone else's possession without identifying it as in answer to "my what...?" Otherwise, aside from these old-fashioned polite rules of usage, as you have seen, there is no reason to consider "...he said of me" and "...he said of yours" as grammatically incorrect.

SUBJECT        OBJECT

I                   me
you               you
he                him
she              her
it                 it
we               us
you              you
they            them

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes