Homework Help

Should pregnant women who use alcohol be incarcerated until they give birthShould...

user profile pic

vladik1 | Student, College Freshman | eNoter

Posted February 24, 2009 at 1:15 PM via web

dislike 2 like
Should pregnant women who use alcohol be incarcerated until they give birth

Should pregnant women who use alcohol be incarcerated until they give birth

20 Answers | Add Yours

user profile pic

linda-allen | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Senior Educator

Posted February 24, 2009 at 1:29 PM (Answer #2)

dislike 0 like

No, they should not. Whether the woman is occasionally using alcohol as in a glass of wine with dinner once or twice, or whether she is abusing alcohol and drinking every day, it is her choice to potentially damage herself and her unborn child. Would you incarcerate a woman to prevent her from having an abortion? If not, why not? What is the difference in the two situations? You can't give a woman the right to choose in one situation and take away that right in another situation.

user profile pic

afi80fl | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Assistant Educator

Posted February 24, 2009 at 2:16 PM (Answer #3)

dislike 0 like

Well, I'll play devil's advocate here and say yes.  I believe it is a form of child abuse, as a parent knowingly inflicts damage on a child through their own doing.  It's no more a parent's choice to drink alcohol while pregnant than it would be for a parent to use electroshock "therapy" to correct their child's behavior in first grade.  There are rules in place to protect voiceless children, even until the age of 18.  If a child complains to a teacher that a parent is neglecting or abusing them, the teacher is lawfully required to report such behavior to the authorities.  How much less should citizens be empowered to call the authorities should they see a woman knowingly and willfully injuring her unborn child?  Not making such a call would be comparable to watching a father punch his daughter in the face while enjoying a hot meal, just to ignore it and move on to dessert.

user profile pic

cburr | Middle School Teacher | (Level 2) Associate Educator

Posted February 24, 2009 at 5:09 PM (Answer #4)

dislike 0 like

It seems to me that incarceration is by no means the best way to deal with this.  Talk about how to ensure that the child has a stable family to be born into!

On the other hand, I agree that seriously endangering a child during pregnancy should not be ignored.

Instead of treating this as a criminal matter -- it's unlikely that the mother is doing it with the intent of harming the child -- it would make more sense for an observer to be able to report the mother to an appropriate authority, such as a hospital.  They would then be given the ability to contact the mother and offer her education and treatment.

user profile pic

jillyfish | Student, Undergraduate | Valedictorian

Posted March 2, 2009 at 7:58 AM (Answer #5)

dislike 0 like

Would you also incarcerate pregnant women who eat too much pizza? Or live in a city with high pollution levels. Or who don't get the recommended 5-a-day green fruit and veg. Or don't excercise. Or if they are over-weight.

Maybe we should lock up women who don't sing to their unborn babies, because their is anecdotal evidence that it is beneficial to children's development. Perhaps pregnant women who are married should be locked up, becauses studies show children with two parents do better. Maybe, to be safe, we should lock up all pregnant women.

I assume your question was a joke.

user profile pic

jessecreations | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Associate Educator

Posted March 2, 2009 at 8:23 AM (Answer #6)

dislike 0 like

I think the heated debate on this topic really comes down to Roe vs. Wade.  If a person believes that a pregnant woman should be allowed to abort her baby, then that person probably also believes that a pregnant woman should be allowed to abuse her unborn baby.  If a person believes abortion should be against the law, then they probably agree that a pregnant woman who drinks during pregnancy is violating some type of right.

I agree that there isn't a way to criminally prosecute a pregnant woman for drinking; but that doesn't mean I don't wish things were different.  If a woman gave an infant whiskey instead of formula, her child's doctor or child care practitioner could refer her to social services and she could be convicted of child abuse.  Yet, because the baby is still part of her own body, she is allowed to mistreat it however she wants.

I think it also should be noted that there is a difference between eating too much pizza and drinking alcohol, in terms of the lasting effect it has on the baby.

Just for a reference, I AM a pregnant woman, and I have had other pregnancies in the past.  I do what I can to provide nutrition and other necessities for my child, just the same way I do that for my children who are already born.  I may not be perfect, and I may not follow all the "rules" of pregnancy to a tee (I admit it - I don't work out as well as I should, and sometimes I eat ice cream, ha ha).  But I also don't do anything that I KNOW will endanger my child's future health, like drinking or doing drugs.  It hurts my heart to see a pregnant woman who smokes cigarettes, for example, because I know that that baby inside of her is smoking too, and he or she didn't have a choice in the matter.

We have all heard horror stories about child abuse, and I would like to think that we all feel heartbroken about it.  In my opinion, this issue is hardly different.  Then again, in my opinion, a fetus is a child just like a toddler is a child, or a teenager is a child.  If a child is being hurt, I wish we would have a system in place that would stop that hurt from happening, no matter WHEN it happens.

user profile pic

dbello | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator

Posted March 5, 2009 at 7:19 PM (Answer #7)

dislike 0 like

I agree with post #4 incarcerating a pregnant woman for drinking acohol is probably not the most productive method of treatment. What would serve a better solution includes educating the individual regarding the risks of abusing acohol while pregnant. Perhaps using the myriad of statistics available to those who seek the information could have a positive influence on the woman. I also believe there should be a distinction between the women who have a glass of red wine at dinner and those abusing acohol while pregnant simply because there is a difference. I think this type of 'across the board condemnation' is a dangerous mentality and is generally counter productive in its intent.  

user profile pic

bohemian | Elementary School Teacher | eNotes Newbie

Posted March 6, 2009 at 3:17 AM (Answer #8)

dislike 0 like

 

From the standpoint of a special education teacher, after years of working with children identified with Fetal Alcohol Syndrome, it is criminal for a pregnant mother to drink alcohol throughout the pregnancy.  The symptoms of FAS range from abnormal behaviors to heart defects and mental retardation with a range of manifestations between.

A better response; however; to prenatal alcohol usage would be education.  Consider mandatory community service for the mother, requiring her to work with a group of FAS children. These same mothers would be required to participate in a proven alcohol rehabilitation program.

For that matter, intervention and education prior to pregnancy is an even better alternative. However, society has accepted alcoholic consumption without question and ignores or is unaware of the effects of alcohol on the unborn child. Until society sees and openly abhors the practice, all the education or even punishment of the mother will have no effect.

user profile pic

engtchr5 | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Associate Educator

Posted March 6, 2009 at 10:39 AM (Answer #9)

dislike 0 like

All life is precious. Every life is valuable. For anyone, female or male, to endanger that life is not just irresponsible, in many cases it is considered illegal. Those who break the law go to jail. It's just that simple.

Having said that, is it societally responsible to incarcerate a pregnant woman, who has many more medical and emotional needs than the average inmate? No, unless it is a very specialized prison situation (where all needs can be provided for; a highly unlikely event). A better approach may be the aforementioned education, but in all honesty, people largely know not to drink or smoke while carrying a child, unless they are in some deprived, third-world type scenario.

So, what is the big answer here? Here in the U.S., the Department of Children and Families (or a similar agency's) intervention in the drinking mother's life could make a difference. A person may report such an act of neglect or abuse to the appropriate agency, and allow the due process to take its course from there. As citizens, that's the best we can do.  

user profile pic

joe30pl | College Teacher | (Level 2) Adjunct Educator

Posted March 10, 2009 at 5:48 PM (Answer #10)

dislike 0 like

Good question. I wish there was a simple "yes/no" answer for this. Obviously, how much alcohol is being consumed? Did the woman in question have any other addictions prior to becoming pregnant? Is she taking anything else? There are several substances, hard drugs and even some prescription medicines, for example, that I would say count. Now, I recognize the fact that someone should intervene, but is it the state's right to do so? This is a slippery slope; a cliche I know, but I feel it best sums up the overall problem. If we make this illegal, what next? Going after women who smoke? Driving recklessly? What about men? if a man smokes near a pregnant woman, could he be charged? Life is not cheap, and one should do everything they can, but is there another way? Education might be the answer. If we at least try to arrest the development and not the parents, then things might work out for the better.  

user profile pic

cahcah | Middle School Teacher | eNotes Newbie

Posted March 15, 2009 at 1:02 PM (Answer #11)

dislike 0 like

I think that it depends on the amount that they are drinking.  If it is a glass of wine at dinner once in a while, no.  However, if they are consuming a great amount, then yes, they are harming their child, and something should be done.  Maybe not incarcerated, but a treatment center or some type of out patient help. 

user profile pic

alohaspirit | Middle School Teacher | (Level 2) Assistant Educator

Posted June 9, 2009 at 7:36 PM (Answer #12)

dislike 0 like

Well if our society was to go to that extreme, then we might as well make abortion illegal. I do not think that should happen or will it ever happen.  

user profile pic

katiep12 | Student, Undergraduate | eNotes Newbie

Posted July 6, 2009 at 6:24 PM (Answer #13)

dislike 0 like

I believe women who drink while pregnant absolutely need to be incarcerated. They damage the babies' brains! If I hit someone in the head and damaged a person's brain I would be tried and convicted and sent to prison. Try raising, teaching, employing, and keeping their offspring out of prison! What they do to their babies is awful! Their kids go through excruciating emotional pain. People who say no have absolutely no idea what these kids have to live like. Why should they go to prison, experience homelessness, joblessness, etc. for their birth mother's mistake.Many are born victims and continue to be victims throughout their lives.

user profile pic

katiep12 | Student, Undergraduate | eNotes Newbie

Posted July 6, 2009 at 6:28 PM (Answer #14)

dislike 0 like

Well if our society was to go to that extreme, then we might as well make abortion illegal. I do not think that should happen or will it ever happen.  

Before this question is responded to people need to educate themselves on the damage that is done. How can anyone say that a person should be able to damage their child's brain?

user profile pic

brendaboline | Student, College Freshman | eNotes Newbie

Posted November 3, 2009 at 4:43 PM (Answer #15)

dislike 0 like

No, they should not. Whether the woman is occasionally using alcohol as in a glass of wine with dinner once or twice, or whether she is abusing alcohol and drinking every day, it is her choice to potentially damage herself and her unborn child. Would you incarcerate a woman to prevent her from having an abortion? If not, why not? What is the difference in the two situations? You can't give a woman the right to choose in one situation and take away that right in another situation.

I find your response bull. I find that if you go along with the pregnancy and drink that is the same as child abuse and should be incarcerated for drinking or abusing drugs while you are pregnant. Even having that glass of wine occasionally is doing harm to the unborn child.Yes, it is a choice of freedom you think, but if that person decided to go thru with the pregnancy and not have an abortion, and from that point on she has to take the responsiblity to take care of herself to give birth to a healthy baby. To intentially drink while you know you are pregnant is abuse. And I apologize if I made this seem like i intended it for you, I didn't, I just feel so strongly on this subject

user profile pic

enotechris | College Teacher | (Level 2) Senior Educator

Posted November 4, 2009 at 6:59 PM (Answer #16)

dislike 0 like

Woman has the right, by virtue of her own birth, to do whatever she wishes with her own body.  You own yourself.  That means you're responsible for yourself.  If she chooses to drink to excess, that's her business, and she alone suffers the consequences of drunkenness.  If she drinks and drives, then she suffers additionally the penalties of the law for endangering others' lives, for others, by virtue of their births, have a right to live and not be endangered by some drunk's actions. However, the question as written presupposes fetuses have rights. If so, then yes, drinking to excess while pregnant is endangering another's life.  But the question isn't even written like that.  If she drinks one drink, is that endangerment?  Is any alcohol near a fetus now a crime? What proof a single drink causes brain damage?  And if "public" health policy deigns that it does, who enforces it?  The fetus police?  Are they the defenders of fetus rights?  And if fetuses have rights, how will they exercise them? Although fetuses may be alive, they're not born, and until such time, they cannot have rights, as they are dependent upon the mother.  As an extension of the mother's body, no one but the mother gets to decide how much to drink, smoke or shoot should they so choose. Certainly those concerned should educate the few errant mothers.  If you attempt to incriminate, you cause more problems and solve none.

user profile pic

snobunnie724 | Student, College Freshman | eNotes Newbie

Posted November 16, 2009 at 5:51 PM (Answer #17)

dislike 0 like

i think it is rediculous that anyone would think it is ok for a woman to drink while she pregnant. i have recently adopted a child with FAS and it is heart breaking. this child did not choose to have a mental retardation and only an ignorant person would be ok with this type of abuse. she is a beautiful little girl that was handicapped by her mother. it could have simply been prevented. women who are reported to be drinking while pregnant should be incarcerated in some kind of institution. we owe it to the children to put something like that into play. if you saw a woman damage her child's brain by smashing a brick into their skull you would do something about it...right?? this situation is no different. if they dont want their child then they should abort not a bring a child into the world that will never be a functioning member of society. its not fair to anyone. especially when a huge number of woman are giving these children up for adoption or putting them into foster care...they are not even dealing with consequences of what they have done.

user profile pic

bakker23 | eNotes Newbie

Posted April 23, 2010 at 6:39 PM (Answer #18)

dislike 0 like
In reply to #2: Abortions should also be illegal. If you do not abort the fetus does it still grow? YES! Therefore abortion is murder.
user profile pic

bakker23 | eNotes Newbie

Posted April 23, 2010 at 6:40 PM (Answer #19)

dislike 0 like

Would you also incarcerate pregnant women who eat too much pizza? Or live in a city with high pollution levels. Or who don't get the recommended 5-a-day green fruit and veg. Or don't excercise. Or if they are over-weight.

Maybe we should lock up women who don't sing to their unborn babies, because their is anecdotal evidence that it is beneficial to children's development. Perhaps pregnant women who are married should be locked up, becauses studies show children with two parents do better. Maybe, to be safe, we should lock up all pregnant women.

I assume your question was a joke.

Are you stupid? "too much pizza"? Your intelligence is a joke, go shoot yourself before you accidently create offspring.

user profile pic

bakker23 | eNotes Newbie

Posted April 23, 2010 at 6:44 PM (Answer #20)

dislike 0 like

i think it is rediculous that anyone would think it is ok for a woman to drink while she pregnant. i have recently adopted a child with FAS and it is heart breaking. this child did not choose to have a mental retardation and only an ignorant person would be ok with this type of abuse. she is a beautiful little girl that was handicapped by her mother. it could have simply been prevented. women who are reported to be drinking while pregnant should be incarcerated in some kind of institution. we owe it to the children to put something like that into play. if you saw a woman damage her child's brain by smashing a brick into their skull you would do something about it...right?? this situation is no different. if they dont want their child then they should abort not a bring a child into the world that will never be a functioning member of society. its not fair to anyone. especially when a huge number of woman are giving these children up for adoption or putting them into foster care...they are not even dealing with consequences of what they have done.

AMEN!!

user profile pic

Wiggin42 | TA , Grade 11 | Valedictorian

Posted June 27, 2014 at 5:37 PM (Answer #21)

dislike 0 like

I think we have to approach this as a social problem. 

certain things need to consider before we pass any illogical laws. Because it doesn't make any sense.In this society women has a right to abort the baby but doesn't have a right to drink while pregnant.

But the question is debatable.

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes