Better Students Ask More Questions.
Should governments have the power to restrict civil rights during crisis situations?im...
5 Answers | add yours
- Espionage and Sedition Acts during WWI.
- The internment of Japanese-Americans on the West Coast in WWII.
- Patriot Act (?)
I suppose that you could answer this by listing various times when governments have tried to restrict civil liberties and rights during times of crisis. You could then look at those incidents and try to determine which of them were (in your opinion) justified and which were not. From there, perhaps you could try to come up with some rules for when governments should be allowed to restrict rights. Or you could come up with reasons why they never should be (if you think that none of the restrictions were justified.
Some examples that I would use would be:
On the other hand, you might look at examples of when governments do not try to restrict civil liberties (like in the US during the Vietnam War or the Gulf War). You could try to discuss what happens when governments don't restrict rights and to determine whether that sheds any light on your question.
Posted by pohnpei397 on November 25, 2010 at 1:13 PM (Answer #2)
I think it doesn't take a lot of power to restrict civil rights, so if the government did not have enough power to do that, then it would not be powerful enough to handle the source of the crisis either.
Perhaps you meant to ask whether the government would be just in restricting civil rights during a crisis.
Posted by geosc on November 25, 2010 at 7:40 PM (Answer #3)
High School Teacher
The problem with government having this power, even when, at times, it may have seemed necessary, is that only government can define when a given situation is a crisis. We would have to assume, for the sake of this argument, that government would only declare a crisis in legitimate emergency situations and that no other motivations on their part other than security of the republic played a part in their actions. This is, unfortunately, rarely the case.
Posted by brettd on December 27, 2010 at 1:43 AM (Answer #4)
According to some peoples beliefs the Bush Administration did this after the 9/11 tragedy. While in my opinion the Patriot Act did not restrict the civil rights of the citizens some feel that it did infringe on the rights of citizens.
Posted by lrwilliams on December 28, 2010 at 7:19 PM (Answer #5)
Middle School Teacher
Posted by litteacher8 on August 12, 2011 at 8:16 AM (Answer #6)
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.