Homework Help

"Les Miserables" indicates the social injustice of France. Please explain about this in...

user profile pic

kaumadhi | Student, Undergraduate | eNotes Newbie

Posted December 22, 2009 at 11:47 PM via web

dislike 2 like

"Les Miserables" indicates the social injustice of France. Please explain about this in relation to the title, with examples.

Victor Hugo's "Les Miserables"

4 Answers | Add Yours

user profile pic

Ashley Kannan | Middle School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted December 23, 2009 at 12:29 AM (Answer #1)

dislike 3 like

Hugo's title seeks to identify the portion of society that most tend to forget.  The downtrodden, the poor, the lower rung, and the dispossessed could very well be described as "the miserable ones.  Literally translated, the title can be seen as "the wretched" and "the criminals."  In focusing so much attention on those who might not receive any, Hugo seems to be making a very strong statement about the nature of social judgment.  When the reader analyzes, like Valjean does, the nature of crime and punishment, need and excess, and justice and fairness, there is a sobering reality that those who are deemed as "the miserable" individuals of society possess an equal chance at happiness as anyone else.  Valjean's condemnation is dubious and disproportionate given the circumstances, and Fantine's hopes of justice are dashed for as a prostitute, she falls under the socially constructed blanked of "les miserables."  To a great extent seen in the conclusion of the play, Hugo's title is a reflection of what is into what should be, in that all individuals are entitled to equality within the law and of opportunity.

user profile pic

mkcapen1 | Middle School Teacher | Valedictorian

Posted December 23, 2009 at 12:26 AM (Answer #2)

dislike 2 like

The book "Les Miserables" begins with a man, Valjean, who is a violent criminal. Through the love of his adopted daughter and the acceptance with unconditional regard by the Bishop of Digne, Valjean, undergoes a transformation into a good person of deep moral conscience.  He is followed throughout his life by another man of good moral conscience, a detective who needs to capture him.  The question of social injustice is a conflict between the detective and Valjean.  Valjean saves the detective which makes the detective question is own understanding of what is justice.  Should he arrest the changed Valjean or should he let him go?  There is no longer a clear line between what is just and what is unjust.

Jean Valjean was initially put into prison where he became hardened because he was trying to obtain food for his sister's hungry children and stole a loaf of bread.  The theme of social injustice is evident because he is of a lower class and poor and the penalty is extremely stiff for his crime.  His misery has caused him to break the law.  He is still targeted after his release because he must show a card telling others he is a criminal, so he can not get work.

The classes are significantly divided.  When the woman dies, who is Collette's mother, because she is the poor child of a prostitute she will be sent to an orphanage where she will be mistreated and worked as if she is slave labor.  Valjean takes the child as his own to prevent her from having a life of misery as a pauper and ward of the state. The prostitute, Fantine, because of her low social status is offered no protection by law after she is badly beaten.  She would never have become a prostitute had her husband lived and there was no alternative way for her to make a living.

There is a class uprising in the book in which the detective is taken as a prisoner.  The population is exhausted by lack of human rights and dignity as they demandchange from the government.  Many of them are killed during the uprising.

user profile pic

Karen P.L. Hardison | College Teacher | eNotes Employee

Posted December 23, 2009 at 12:31 AM (Answer #3)

dislike 2 like

The English translation of Les Miserables is "the miserable." Victor Hugo identifies "the miserable" as the poor men, women and children of France making the connection between them and misery by setting many scenes on the streets and by contrasting their lives and experiences to that of the elite classes.  

Social injustice--which Hugo demonstrates to encompass the transformation of good people into thieves and criminals through restrictions related to social goods like education, employment, access to food, opportunity to better oneself, gender and class equality, uniformity of standards governing behavior--is connected to the poor people of France, represented by Paris, through the experiences of characters like Valjean and Fantine who are compared to Myriel and contrasted against the Patron-Minette and Tholomyès.

user profile pic

mwestwood | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted December 23, 2009 at 3:46 AM (Answer #4)

dislike 2 like

To draw another analogy, Victor Hugo is the French version of the English Charles Dickens.  Contemporaries in time, both men perceived the tremendous gap between the upper classes and those in the lower.  While Dickens described society as a "prison" in which few, if any, could rise above their position in society, Hugo writes of Jean Valjean, condemned unjustly to prison, who escapes the physical prison, but is unable to escape the "prison" of always having been a criminal. 

For one thing, he must carry a yellow card identifying himself as a criminal.  As a result, he cannot find work, and, in desperation--a state which precipitated his first crime--he steals the candle stands from the bishop.  It is only because of the charity of the bishop who tells the gendarmes that Valjean was given these valuables by him that Valjean, a "miserable," a chance in life.  And, with this chance, Valjean redeems himself in many ways, practicing the same charity towards other "miserables" such as Fantine and Collette. Nevertheless, he remains condemned by society and is constantly pursued by Inspector Javert until the end of Javert's life.

Similarly, in Dickens's "Great Expectations" in which Magwitch, an unfortunate "wretch"--a "miserable" who also has stolen to keep from starving--escapes from the prison ship on which he has been sentenced after his complicity with a gentleman who has taken advantage of him and strives to redeem himself in New South Wales.  After he becomes a wealthy sheep farmer, he acts as Pip's benefactor, but he is still condemned by the "prison" of society, and cannot escape the fate of England's laws.  Thus, both Dickens and Hugo write of the miserable fate of the poor, who albeit good in soul, cannot redeem themselves in society.

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes