In "Hamlet" how does the theme of deception inevitably lead to the death of Hamlet and Claudius?My original thesis was relating deception to the lose of the relationships between characters but...

In "Hamlet" how does the theme of deception inevitably lead to the death of Hamlet and Claudius?

My original thesis was relating deception to the lose of the relationships between characters but thought that relating deception to death would be more interesting. Basically, how does Hamlet's deception of acting mad lead to his death? and how does Claudius's deception of hiding his act of killing King Hamlet lead to his death?If you believe that the original thesis was better, please explain how you would elaborate it.


Asked on by mballaz

2 Answers | Add Yours

jseligmann's profile pic

jseligmann | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Associate Educator

Posted on

Claudius' attempt at deception gets him nowhere because the Ghost spills the beans. That Hamlet will kill him is all but certain; the question is merely when. So, deception doesn't lead to his death; he's not fooling the Ghost nor the person chosen to kill him.

Deception is a lot more problematic for Prince Hamlet, however. As soon as the Ghost tells him to avenge his "foul and most unnatural murder" at the hands of his brother, Hamlet embarks on a plan for the revenge which involves lots of tricks and deception. He has his reasons for this, but, as time passes, the risks of being discovered increase. His safest move would have been to immediately kill Claudius, and his deception puts him in jeopardy and it eventually kills him.

In short: Claudius is undone by his deed, not his deception. Hamlet is undone by the amount of time he took to take his revenge, and his need for deception took the time.

The marked difference between the two characters in regard to the theme of deception makes for a weak thesis. Sorry.

mrs-campbell's profile pic

mrs-campbell | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Hamlet originally thinks that putting on "an antic disposition" and acting mad will avert suspicion from his investigations in his father's murder. He figures that if he starts snooping around, Claudius will take notice and be alarmed, and possibly cause Hamlet harm.  But, if he's acting mad, people will just dismiss any unusual inquiries or behavior, because it's just the nutty Hamlet being kooky again.  Unfortunately, this plan doesn't work out too well.  Hamlet's strange behavior concerns Ophelia and Polonius, and the Queen, and as a result, they all watch Hamlet even more closely.  The Queen is so concerned that she has Polonius hide in her bedroom during Hamlet's visit, which leads to Polonius's death, which leads in part to Ophelia's madness, which in part leads to Laertes's challenge of Hamlet to a duel, which in part leads to Hamlet's death.  Did you catch the chain reaction there?  Hamlet severely mistreats Ophelia because he knows he's being watched; he's being watched because he's been acting strangely.  His mistreatment of Ophelia in that scene is also part of what leads to her insanity and death, which prompts Laertes to murder also.  So, Hamlet's deceptive behavior leads to people's deaths, which leads to his own.

As far as Claudius goes, if he hadn't murdered his brother, Hamlet would have never sworn revenge against him.  If he hadn't hidden the murder and taken up with King Hamlet's wife, Hamlet Jr. wouldn't have been so vilely angry at him either, and desired to kill him.  Claudius's deception prompts his secretive death warrant on Hamlet given to Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, and it is that action that finally pushes Hamlet over the edge into full-blown revenge mode.  Claudius's deceptive reasons for Laertes challenging Hamlet also indirectly leads to his death.  Claudius's deception about the poisoned wine leads to his wife's death, and alerts Hamlet to his insidious intentions, which then prompts Hamlet to make the final move and kill him.

I hope that all of those connections made sense and helped; good luck!

We’ve answered 317,385 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question