Homework Help

Explain the irony found in the Ethan Frome.at least three examples, situations and/or...

user profile pic

osufan2442 | Student, Undergraduate | eNoter

Posted January 4, 2011 at 11:22 PM via web

dislike 1 like

Explain the irony found in the Ethan Frome.

at least three examples, situations and/or details to support your topic sentence.

2 Answers | Add Yours

user profile pic

lmetcalf | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Senior Educator

Posted January 5, 2011 at 12:25 AM (Answer #1)

dislike 1 like

This novel is filled with different types and examples of irony.  The most obvious examples are found within the ending of the novel.  It is great situational irony that Ethan intends to commit suicide with Mattie, but ends up merely crippling both of them.  This seems worse than death, especially considering the ironic change in Mattie's behavior.  Where she once was a light and caring person, she has aged into a bitter and cantakerous older woman who is miserable her in wrecked body and wrecked life.

It is ironic that the once very feeble and sickly Zeena is now the strong and capable woman at the end of the novel. It would seem that she is very able-bodied when she needs to be.  Once Ethan and Mattie need her to care for them, she rises to the occasion.  It is a revisiting of the plot element that brought her to the Fromes in the first place.  She is caring for an invalid again.

It is ironic that Ethan was unwilling to leave Zeena and run away with Mattie, but his choice is now a double punishment because he is still with Zeena, but he also has to daily face the invalid Mattie and a) remember what she used to be to him, and b) put up with her negatively changed behavior.

Other ironic occurances: 

1.Mattie only reveals that she loves Ethan when he driving her out of town to catch a train.  It seems to suggest a manipulative nature in Mattie, but it ends up destroying them both. 

2. Ethan only asks Zeena to marry him because he can't bear to face a winter alone.  If his mother had died in spring or summer, he would likely have returned to school and left Starkfield for good.

The list could obviously go on, but these are a few big and small ideas to get you started! 

user profile pic

udonbutterfly | Student, College Freshman | Valedictorian

Posted September 29, 2014 at 10:28 PM (Answer #2)

dislike 0 like

Ethan Frome has so much irony in it you can basically pin point any scene and make it out to have irony as long as you support it well. Three things with irony that really stood out to me would be:

First: How Zeena was able to take care of Ethan's mom so well when in reality it is probably due to the fact that Zeena was ill her self and Ethan was unable to see.

-When Ethan talks about his mom and then transitions to talk about Zeena.  He mentions that Zeena took care of his mother so well and that maybe it was because she was sick as well.

Second: Ethan dreams of living in a big city and getting out of town but the irony in this is that the only way it seems to leave this town is through death.

-You can see this in the grave stone scene and it haves Ethan's name on it.

Third: Throughout the book we are al aware of the strong sense of responsibility Ethan has to take care of the farm and Zeena however when he finally let the reigns go--and goes slaying with Mattie-- ever things come down crashing and burning and now he has to take care of both Zeena and Mattie.

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes