Better Students Ask More Questions.
Discuss the role that Duncan plays in The Edible Woman.DUNCAN IS A YOUNG GRADUATE...
Topic: The Edible Woman
Discuss the role that Duncan plays in The Edible Woman.
DUNCAN IS A YOUNG GRADUATE STUDENT WHOM MARIAN MEETS AT A LAUNDROMAT AND WITH WHOM SHE DEVELOPS A FRIENDSHIP. LIKE MARIAN, HE CANNOT ADOPT TO THE EXPECTATIONS OF CONVENTIONAL SOCIETY, BUT DUNCAN SIMPLY REFUSES TO CARE. HE IS BORED WITH STUDIES BUT DOESN'T LEAVE THEM. MOST OF THE TIME HE RELIES ON HIS ROOMMATES TO SEE THAT HE IS FED AND ALSO KEPT HEALTHY. HE REFUSES TO MAKE CHOICES. WHEN THEY MAKE LOVE WITH MARIAN, DUNCAN SHOWS NO EMOTIONS AND INDICATES NO DESIRE FOR A MORE SERIOUS RELATIONSHIONSHIP.HE REPRESENTS ONE OF THE CHOICES AVAILABLE TO MARIASN, A CHOICE THAT SHE REJECTS.
1 Answer | add yours
High School Teacher
If Marion's fiance Peter is the confident, well put together, organized, perfectionist - than Duncan is his opposite.
I think what you have so far is a pretty accuate description of him - but let's analyze. Here is a woman who does not exactly know what she wants, and is drawn to two completely opposite men. Both men represent the two sides of what most women want in companionship. On one hand, Peter represents the confidence, stability, and consistency that women look for when thinking about a worry-free future. Duncan on the other hand, represents spontanaiety, inconsistency, and that laid-back approach to life that says, "I take things as they come."
What Marion really needs is a balance between the two. As in most cases however, Peter is not enough. In fact, he is a bit shallow - and Marion begins to not only realize this, but that Peter wants her to evolve into perfection for him. Duncan on the other hand, is not enough either. He is enticing and fun. In fact, he helps Marion discover who she really is because at first, she wishes to impress him (perhaps be more "real" like him) but when she realizes he is just as shallow as Peter, she starts to understand what she really wants and needs, based on what these men aren't.
Posted by clairewait on August 10, 2010 at 10:53 PM (Answer #1)
Related QuestionsSee all »
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.