Discuss the nature of tragedy in Dubliners by James Joyce.

2 Answers | Add Yours

susan3smith's profile pic

susan3smith | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Educator

Posted on

In the opening story "The Sisters" from The Dubliners, you might find the answer to the question in the italicized words:  gnomon, paralysis, and simony.  These form the heart of what plagues the characters in these short stories.

Paralysis is the most pervasive cause of the individual characters' tragedies.  The characters are trapped by their poverty, routine, religion or sense of duty, or the past.  In "Araby," the narrator longs to escape the drudgery of his surroundings and sees Mangan's sister as a key to that escape.  Going to the bazaar to find her a gift gives him a sense of purpose, a mission that blinds him to the drabness of his surroundings.  Bitter and disillusioned at the end of the story, the narrator finds that there is no Araby in Dublin.  Eveline is another character whose tragedy is her inability to escape; she is paralyzed by her sense of duty, her obligations to her family, her fear of the unknown, and at the end of the story she cannot go to Buenos Aires with Frank and becomes a "helpless creature."

But the other two words are also keys to the tragedies that face the characters in these stories.  Religious corruption or blindly following religious routines is the heart of "The Sisters."  Many stories have the symbol of a dead priest or empty chalice to show the inability of the church to provide true inspiration to its members.

The gnomon is a parallelogram with a smaller parallelogram taken out.  The idea of a missing piece or obscured truth is prominent in many of the stories, but most specifically in "The Dead," when Gabriel realizes that he did not know his wife at all (a missing piece) and that he cannot compete with a ghost from his wife's past.

booboosmoosh's profile pic

booboosmoosh | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

James Joyce's collection of stories entitled Dubliners deals with people who live in and around Dublin, as James Joyce did himself growing up.  The group of stories study and present "portraits" of Dublin's real life working class.

Most of the people in Dubliners are poor.   Each story portrays characters that are looking for something important, but find that life is not what they expect or they are wishing for.  They are not able to enjoy themselves; they see life as a series of obstacles where disappointment and sadness leave them unfulfilled.  In some cases there is hopelessness, in one there is even enormous guilt.

Although the stories are about different people, the thread of commonality runs through all of them--not in the same pitfalls or challenges they face, but in the tragic experiences which generally define their daily lives: living in poverty and disillusionment, experiencing an inability to act, and finding themselves unable to find the happiness they so fervently desire.


We’ve answered 317,661 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question