Homework Help

Is Milton's Paradise Lost an epic?

user profile pic

hibo | Student, Undergraduate | (Level 2) Honors

Posted May 29, 2010 at 5:09 AM via web

dislike 1 like

Is Milton's Paradise Lost an epic?

2 Answers | Add Yours

Top Answer

user profile pic

mstultz72 | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted May 29, 2010 at 7:47 AM (Answer #1)

dislike 3 like

John Milton's Paradise Lost is the only and, therefore, greatest English epic. The poem is an epic but also an collection of ideas and abstractions (-isms).  Milton intended the epic to be a "new vision"--a reinterpretation of the Great Biblical Story for modern man.  Milton was the last optimistic poet in the English language, even though he was blind and had no reason to be.  After all, the great metaphor for the poem is not the Fall, but the Renewal and Redemption of mankind.  Milton clearly champions absolute freedom of the individual: "to the pure, all things pure; to the impure, all things impure."

Milton had a vision and a philosophy.  Other great poets (like Shakespeare) did not (thank God!).  Milton's poetry is nationalistic, Christian humanist, anti-Catholic.  Milton considers himself the poet prophet, capable of reinterpreting the Bible and also following Aristotle's Golden Mean (moderation).

Other notes that make Paradise Lost the only English epic:

  • Redemptive nature of Christ; Jesus assumed the form of man to bridge the gap between man and God
  • Hell is not the center of the earth (like Dante's cosmos); Earth dangles from Heaven; it is a pedant world, dependent on heaven.
  • It is the story of "original sin" (greatest of topics: souls are at stake)
  • Milton the great poet-prophet interjects himself and instructs often.
  • Hopeful ending
  • Each paragraph/stanza represents an idea (catalogue method)
  • Main idea: a paradise with no choice is no paradise: no virtue occurs in a vacuum.  Man must be tempted.
  • Satan only appears to be heroic: "better to reign in heaven than serve in hell."  Although, the epic begins with him, and he is the most developed character in the epic.  He is a parody of Christ, and hell is a parody of heaven.

Top Answer

user profile pic

mrceolsen | College Teacher | (Level 1) eNoter

Posted May 29, 2010 at 8:46 AM (Answer #2)

dislike 3 like

Paradise Lost is also epic in two senses: one, as an allegory of the mind, and particularly the way envy causes harm, but also is necessary for creativity; and two, a political allegory dealing with issues that occurred in Milton's England. 

Milton was alive during a time known as the interregnum, which was a time when England didn't have a king or queen.  Milton was a strong political voice, and even imprisoned for beliefs.  He was probably very fortunate not to have been killed.  He was strongly against reinstating a kingdom. 

Psychologically, or perhaps spiritually, the text could be perhaps termed a map of the mind, like Dante's Commedia, or Blake's works. 

It is not true that Paradise Lost is the only British epic, as The Fairie Queene, rarely read, but something Milton would have read and admired, and also Blake's works Milton & Jeruselem.  Of course one wonders if the early British epic Beowulf counts.  Perhaps some of Wordsworth also counts.

Satan is in a sense the epic hero - but he is flawed and mistaken and causes the state we are now in - outcast from eden.  Interpretations of this, however, are markedly different.  Some who are religious argue Satan is evil.  Others, however, look at Satan and Eve as having done good for helping humans become active - without eating from the tree of knowledge, man would be sort of a vegetable.  Thus, the idea might be, without envy, we humans would perhaps be very passive and not learn.  Some even argue that whatever god is really wanted us to eat from the tree; after all, if you give someone free will, but forbid them something - well...

Thus, perhaps we can argue that this epic is about a tragic hero that seemingly unlike Beowulf we are supposed to hate, but that works like Beowulf to do some evil or injury to man.  Beowulf as an epic hero has to be read ironically unless we read it as coercive and propagandistic. 

Perhaps thus it also seeks to undermine the blind patriotism or nationalism created by the Beowulf and similar epics, and instead create an epic accepting of the need for dissidence and learning. 

One of the beautiful poetic elements of Paradise Lost is its use of simile: Milton compares the acts of the devils & Satan to things in reality and history, and the implication seems to be that reality absorbs and conquers envy, or hatred.  Whatever humans do or create - even if it is evil - can be absorbed by reality and by good.  This receptivity is a beautiful feature of reality we might not see so well except for Milton's vision. 

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes