Better Students Ask More Questions.
Please give an explanation as to why Hamlet treats Ophelia the way he does in the...
2 Answers | add yours
High School Teacher
There are a number of options you have in explaining Hamlet's behaviour towards Ophelia in Act III scene 1, the famous nunnery scene, where Hamlet is rather cruel towards her. One of my favourite adaptions of this play is the Kenneth Brannagh version, which suggests the reason why Hamlet is so cruel towards Ophelia is that he becomes aware that their conversation is being watched by Polonius and Claudius. This of course represents a betrayal of Ophelia towards him, and in this version Hamlet is grief-stricken by yet another betrayal of somebody whom he loves. Yet if we think about it, how a director stages this scene is necessarily going to revolve around a question that the text does not answer for us: is Hamlet aware of Claudius and Polonius and at what point does he become aware of them?
The way a director answers this question will of course have massive ramifications in terms of Hamlet and how his character is played in this scene. If he remains ignorant of their presence, then this scene strongly suggests Hamlet's madness and the way that he is losing control of himself. If he is aware of their presence, this could be a scene where he uses Ophelia, just as Ophelia has used him, to continue to present his "antic disposition" to the King. Being aware of the presence of Polonius and Claudius also gives another further option: Hamlet is so cruel to Ophelia because she has been so cruel to him in betraying him and setting him up.
Posted by accessteacher on July 29, 2011 at 8:54 PM (Answer #1)
The ' Nunnery Scene ' of Act III of Hamlet. Claudius and Polonius make a plan to find out if Hamlet's unrequited love for Ophelia is the real cause of his madness. For this purpose they employ Ophelia to act as a decoy to talk to Prince Hamlet while they hide themselves behind the curtains to overhear their conversation. Ophelia agrees to play her part but she does it in a clumsy manner. Soon Hamlet realises that she is acting as a spy on behalf of the King. This enrages him. He becomes harsh and sarcastic and repeatedly asks Ophelia not to marry but to go a Nunnery to spend there the rest of her life.
This scene proves that Ophelia is a weak-willed girl who readily submits to the dictates of her father. This extreme docility and submissiveness is a weakness in her character which makes a definite contribution to the tragedy of Hamlet and of her own. Her repentance though sincere was meaningless because Hamlet is out of the scene by then.
Posted by nandini289 on August 10, 2011 at 12:21 AM (Answer #2)
Related QuestionsSee all »
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.