Is the United States a democracy or a republic?
3 Answers | Add Yours
There is no way to say this for certain as the difference between a democracy and a republic is not very clear at all. Different people use the terms differently. The US is clearly not a direct democracy. We vote for people who represent us rather than voting directly on laws ourselves. This means we are either an indirect democracy or a republic, but these terms are typically used interchangeably.
Some entities make another type of distinction between a republic and a democracy. In their view, a republic makes a priority of protecting the minority rights. "Minority" in this sense does not just refer to a racial or cultural subgroup, but to any group that is not in the majority on any particular issue. Certain rights are protected no matter what. In a "democracy," according to this interpretation, rights could be selectively granted based on majority rule. For example, citizens who oppose unionization could attempt to pass a law denying unions freedom of speech.
To sum up, in this view, a republic seeks to keep minorities from being overwhelmed and outvoted by majorities when it comes to applying rights.
Another major component of a republic is, as post 2 stated, the election of representatives to serve certain electoral areas.
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.Join eNotes