Better Students Ask More Questions.
How does Steinbeck incorporate themes of naturalism into The Grapes of Wrath?
3 Answers | add yours
- The supernatural as only a development of the natural
- Characters are fully developed early in the narrative in order that the reader may be an informed observer.
- An Objective Tone
High School Teacher
This novel of Steinbeck, like much of his fiction, does not make for comfortable reading, as he seeks to exemplify how naturalism can impact a family like the Joads. Naturalism is a philosophical belief that argues so much of our lives as humans is determined by factors that are beyond our control, such as our environment. It presents humans as being defenceless in a world where actually, in spite of all our strength and technology, we are shown to be incredibly weak and our lives are left so much to chance.
Steinbeck explores this belief explicitly through documenting the migration of the Joads, who, like so many other families, were forced to trek for miles in search of work. He describes how the "shining red earth" impacts their characters, and ultimately, in spite of the considerable strength and resilience of the Joads, their attempt to determine their own lives and futures is shown to be futile against the forces of naturalism, that seem to enter their "souls where the grapes of wrath are filling and growing heavy." The title of this novel, therefore, refers to the ways in which so many things that happen to us in life have nothing to do with our character or our personality: the forces of nature transcend and expose our limitations as humans, ultimately humbling us.
Posted by accessteacher on June 19, 2012 at 8:23 AM (Answer #1)
High School Teacher
In reaction to the Great Depression and the 1930 Dust Bowl, John Steinbeck wrote the 1939 novel The Grapes of Wrath, which won the Pulitzer Prize.
Naturalism is a literary focus on man as an inhabitant of his environment, rather than as a social creature, and studies human interaction as it pertains to the world around. The Joad family, traveling to California in search of a better life, are defined almost entirely by their surroundings, adapting to new situations and becoming stronger after each obstacle. At the beginning, leaving the dead soil of Oklahoma behind, they are simple, "piled in John's house like gophers in a winter burrow" (Steinbeck). The comparison to animals continues throughout the book, showing how the thinking animal -- humans -- still must react to and defend from the environment and predators around them. By showing the Joad's plight in terms of the hostile world, Steinbeck is able to use them as an allegory for survival of the fittest in both the animal and human kingdoms. The Joads are small creatures, but they persist as a whole; even as individual members die, the collective remains. By the end of the novel, the Joads have a greater understanding of the world, good and bad, and of their own capacity for moral choice and survival.
Posted by belarafon on February 9, 2012 at 6:41 AM (Answer #2)
In his essay "A Defense of Naturalism," Roger Sherman Loomis declares,
...the Naturalist discards as obsolete three supernaturalistic concepts—Providence, absolute morality, and freedom of the will.
Steinbeck's character Jim Casy exemplifies this concept. He has been a preacher, but he has abandoned the traditional role. Instead, he tries to serve people by working with them and by setting an example. He tells the Joads, "Maybe all men got one big soul everybody's a part of." He discards the idea of Jesus as savior and says that men must work together in order to attain anything. And, only reason enhanced by experience can direct people to the truth. Through such characters as Casy and Ma Joad and Tom in his novel The Grapes of Wrath, Steinbeck portrays man as a highly complex creature, whose nature includes, besides his natural urges, a social and artistic instincts as well as reason. If all these factor are in harmony, happiness can be attained.
Steinbeck's novel presents "the environment and nature’s effects on social history." The great French Nauralist, Emile Zola, explains the idea of determinism as the theory that a person's fate is determined solely by heredity and environment. Many of Steinbeck's intercalary chapters portray this determinism. For example, in Chapter Five the description of the spokesman for the land owners informing the sharecroppers of their fates that they must leave the land on which their families have lived for generations. Even the owner men feel “caught in something larger than themselves” as the banks dictate to them. However, the Naturalist does not always make everyone a complete victim of fate; there are those who work together and are able to endure. The Joads, for example, represent the social group, the unit of strength that abides throughout, no matter the cost to them individually.
In The Grapes of Wrath, characters are described with much detail and are introduced early in the narrative. Tom Joad and Jim Casy are well developed by Chapter Four. And, Ma Joad and the rest of the Joad family is introduced and characterized by Chapter Eight.
The theme of "the cause of labor" is typically Naturalistic. Steinbeck's main objective in his narrative is the illustration of the dispossed Oklahoma farmers who must migrate and seek work where there none or where there is much injustice.
Another typical theme is that of "ordinary people in extraordinary circumstances." The Joads and others like them find themselves and all their worldly belongings traveling down unknown highways, alienated from friends and familiar surroundings as they search for work.
Naturalists employ symbolism, and Steinbeck utilizes the Joad family as representative of the larger "family of humanity." Especially poignant and meaningful is Rose of Sharon's giving literally of the "milk of human kindness" to the starving man. Another symbol is the land, which represents the people themselves and their histories.
The narrator of this novel maintains an objective attitude toward the characters, observing their behaviors in a scientific way of merely recording the details of what characters do and say in response to natural forces.
Posted by mwestwood on June 19, 2012 at 8:13 AM (Answer #3)
Related QuestionsSee all »
Join to answer this question
Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.