Homework Help

Cost of illegal immigrants to taxpayersI am trying to develop a sound thesis concerning...

user profile pic

squishy03

Posted November 29, 2010 at 4:30 AM via web

dislike 0 like
Cost of illegal immigrants to taxpayers

I am trying to develop a sound thesis concerning the staggering cost associated with illegal immigrants. The cost to our social welfare programs, schools opening and being staffed with 100% illegal immigrant children enrollment, healthcare, American jobs, and the death toll on our highways. All of this in the name of "cheap labor."

This NOT a report meant to come across as racist; I merely want to state the facts. I'm certain at least some people on this site will be offended, but it is not my intention; there is no way to paint a subject report that begins with the title "Illegal Immigration" in a positive light. This is my assignment.

Personal feelings aside, can anyone help me begin this thing with an opening line that states why American taxpayers are so frustrated with this particular sect of people without coming across as though it's filled with venom?

8 Answers | Add Yours

user profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted November 29, 2010 at 6:19 AM (Answer #2)

dislike 0 like

First of all, I urge you to be cautious about your claims.  If I were an instructor reading your paper, my first thing would be to look for unsubstantiated claims.  So make sure that you have credible sources before you talk about schools that are 100% illegal, etc.

Second, are you sure that it is the economic cost that bothers Americans most?  (BTW, sect is not the right term here --- a sect is more of a religious group.)  My feeling is that what really bothers Americans is the fact that the people are illegal -- not how much they cost the taxpayers.

Which brings me to my third point -- studies I have read disagree on the impact of illegals on American taxpayers.  The disagreement comes because it is very hard to quantify how much illegals actually cost -- it is guesswork because data are not accurately gathered as to the immigration status of students, etc.  Remember also that illegals who are "legally" employed are paying taxes (Social Security and Medicare at least) without being able to participate in those programs later.  Anyway, the cost is not necessarily easy to quantify.

If I had to write about why Americans are frustrated, I would only say that economics is one small part.  I'd start it by saying something like

As economic times have grown harder and as more and more illegal immigrants have come to this country, American citizens have, for a number of reasons, become upset about the issue of illegal immigration.

From there, it depends on what you are really trying to argue -- are you trying to explain why Americans are mad or are you trying to argue that illegals cost us a lot of money?

Whatever you argue, you're not going to sound racist if your facts are accurate and you do not use incendiary language.  Also be sure to present both sides of the issue (like with the part about how illegals actually pay in to the Social Security system without being able to get anything out).

user profile pic

brettd | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Educator Emeritus

Posted November 29, 2010 at 8:10 PM (Answer #3)

dislike 0 like

#2 is a great post with sound advice on writing about this subject.

Another way to approach this (and arguing with fact rather than emotion is always more effective persuasion) is to express Americans' frustrations as part of a historical pattern.  Immigrants have been coming here in waves for almost two centuries.  Each time, a predictable pattern emerges, where the existing and dominant American culture feels threatened by the influx of new language and religion into cities, schools and the public, and there is typically a popular and legal backlash against these newcomers, whether they be Latinos in the modern day, Irish in the 1840s or Germans and Italians in the 1880s.

Another way to approach the subject is to highlight the right of sovereign nations to control who and what crosses their frontiers and under what circumstances.  That is, no country can long survive with open borders.

I have seen similar studies suggesting that illegal immigrants economic contributions, in terms of taxes they do pay, and the cost savings to Americans in terms of food and product prices being lower, offsetting much if not all of their economic cost in social services.  I don't know if any of those numbers can ever be definitively proven.

user profile pic

squishy03

Posted November 30, 2010 at 8:45 AM (Answer #4)

dislike 0 like

It's a difficult topic to tackle for sure. From the oodles of reports, documentaries, and web information(always questionable) that I've read, legal citizens are frustrated for many reasons.

The abuse of social welfare programs, emergency rooms being frequented for coughs and colds in turn driving the cost of our healthcare through the roof, schools being funded (yes, we have several here in Northeast Georgia) that are 100% enrolled with children of illegal immigrants or illegal themselves.

Another study showed the deplorable state of our Nation's malls and department stores! :) I'm not a shopper...I loathe it. I had no idea this was a problem, but after reading the initial report I did some more checking, and what do you know?! There is evidence of this in virtually every state.

 

We live in the North Ga. Mts. and my family volunteers twice/week at a local food pantry. There is a sweet hispanic family who comes in for food each week. They were just refused last week because the mother was reported (and proven guilty) of collecting food from the pantry for free, then going back to her makeshift home/diner and cooking the food to sell to local construction workers. It is so difficult to deal with this issue anymore without forming a negative opinion.

I do not blame anyone for wanting a better life. But where do we draw the line for personal responsibility?

 

user profile pic

scarletpimpernel | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted December 1, 2010 at 6:47 PM (Answer #5)

dislike 0 like

You've received sound advice from the other posters. Here are several other points you might consider.

1. Do illegal immigrants have any effect on costs associated with crimes? For example, are they incarcerated at a higher rate than legal immigrants or citizens? If so, then you could discuss the burden that it places on taxpayers to pay for public defenders, prison housing, etc.

2. Do illegal immigrants increase unemployment for the general American population? If they do, then that would place more of a burden on taxpayers because they (we) pay for unemployment benefits.

3. How much money has been spent in the past three decades to train ESL teachers and develop programs for non-native English students? Be careful with this, though, because you will have to look at statistics for legal and illegal immigrant children.

To write a logical argument on any topic but especially on such a controversial topic as this, you need to try to stay away from emotional fallacies. Stick to the facts; carry out thorough research, and approach the paper with an open mind. You should also consider adding a concession to your paper which demonstrates that you recognize that there are benefits to America's accepting immigrants. This does not mean that you contradict yourself, but you need to show that you know what the other side's argument is and that you see some merit in it.

user profile pic

lrwilliams | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator

Posted December 5, 2010 at 2:14 PM (Answer #6)

dislike 0 like

The above posts have all given you great advice. I would ask that in doing a paper on a topic that tends to evoke lots of emotion it is important to use verifiable facts to support your argument and to try and stay with those points of fact.

user profile pic

mwestwood | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted July 25, 2011 at 7:12 AM (Answer #7)

dislike 0 like

In your research, you may wish to look at the statistics on the state of California. There will be actual documented facts and figures that will not be unsubstantiated regarding the cost of illegal immigrants. 

The logic that illegals do not cost the United States money or the cost of illegal immigrants living in the U.S. cannot be substantiated is the same thinking as that of believing that the cost of welfare to all working Americans, regardless of their races, is not substantial.

user profile pic

litteacher8 | Middle School Teacher | (Level 1) Distinguished Educator

Posted July 28, 2011 at 12:30 PM (Answer #8)

dislike 0 like
The biggest costs are the cost of education and health care. Since many illegal immigrants work under the table and do not pay taxes, some people say that they are not paying their fair share. They also go to the emergency room for routine health care, which ends up costing more.
user profile pic

user1497588

Posted July 27, 2014 at 4:03 AM (Answer #9)

dislike 0 like

My name is Brown Mark and am from USA,let me share this testimony to the world to hear  about him too this man really exit I was HIV positive over 6year I have being in medication and I try to look for cure to my problem and I go through internet doctor and I found a tradition named DR. CAFAI i contacted cafaispiritualtemple@yahoo.com for help he give me all his laws and rule that if I get cured I should write about him and that is what am doing now, this man ask for some information about me, which I give him this man cure me from HIV what a great man thank for your help when he get the information he told me that he is about to work on it 20 to 30 minute this man email me and told me what to do for the curing which I did after all the things needed for the cure is provide the man call me in 45mins later and tell me to go for test what a great day to me I was negative thanks Dr CAFAi you can through his email address,cafaispiritualtemple@yahoo.com or his phone number +234 7067607073

Images:
This image has been Flagged as inappropriate Click to unflag
Image (1 of 1)

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes