Homework Help

Can you please read my psychology ERA introduction and suggest areas in which it can be...

user profile pic

jasseb | Student, Grade 10 | eNoter

Posted October 25, 2011 at 1:53 PM via web

dislike 0 like

Can you please read my psychology ERA introduction and suggest areas in which it can be improved?

Introduction

The relationship between birth-order and personality has been a topic of interest amongst psychologists.  Grivas & Carter (2010) suggested that First Born Children were conscientious, responsible and developed a higher degree of leadership skills due to caring for their younger siblings.  Later Born children were quoted being “sociable and good at maintaining relationships in later life” (p. 544).  Only children were also said to “seem more self- confident… [as] a result of their having no competition (p.544)”. Grivas and Carter also suggested this was due to the fact that each child is raised in a different family environment and stated that research studies have found the influence to be minimal.  Studying the effects of birth order will provide insight onto how specific environmental factors affect the development on personality.  The research study aims to investigate the existence and type of relationship between ordinal position of first and later born children, only children and personality. It was hypothesized that the participants, first, later or only born children sampled through convenience would produce considerably varied results on a personality rating survey, thus indicating minimal correlation between the two variables.

 

3 Answers | Add Yours

Top Answer

user profile pic

thanatassa | College Teacher | (Level 2) Educator Emeritus

Posted October 25, 2011 at 3:19 PM (Answer #1)

dislike 2 like

The first sentence doesn't really say anything and should be deleted. Instead, you need to open with a sense of what the paper is actually doing. Is it a precis of an article? A critical analysis? Is this an argumentative paper? What is the actual point you are trying to make here?

In analyzing this study, one important issue would be sample size and method of selecting samples. Then, you might look at methodology -- how did they actually assess the traits they attribute to birth order? What was the statistical significance of their results (what sort of significance tests did they do? how far did their results vary from a random distribution?) Was there any possibility of observer bias?

Finally, has this study been replicated by other psychologists and were the results identical?

For language, chose one verb tense to use throughout the paper rather than changing tense (why are you using future tense to discuss a study completed last year?) and watch out for overuse of passive voice.

user profile pic

ebojoy | Middle School Teacher | Honors

Posted October 25, 2011 at 10:17 PM (Answer #2)

dislike 0 like

 

Hello.  Overall, your introduction is one of quality and correct usage of the APA style.  Your introduction could be improved, however, by using the correct prepositions and verb tense.  I also think you would do well to use the word/term “latter” instead of “later,” although this may or may not improve your paper.  I have taken the liberty of editing your introduction.  I hope this is helpful.

For decades, the relationship between birth-order and personality has been a topic of great interest among psychologists.  Grivas & Carter (2010) suggested that first-born children are more conscientious, responsible and develop a higher degree of leadership skills, due to their participation in the care of their younger siblings.  Later-born children were characterized as being “sociable and good at maintaining relationships in later life” (p. 544).  Only children were also said to “seem more self- confident… [as] a result of their having no competition (p.544).” Grivas and Carter also suggest the personality differences between first-born, later-born, and only children are due to the fact that each of them are raised in different family environments; however, the research shows this influence to be minimal. It is hypothesized that the study participants, first, later, or only born children sampled through convenience will produce considerably varied results on a personality rating survey, thus indicating minimal correlation between the two variables.

user profile pic

kedirassefatessema | Student , Undergraduate | eNotes Newbie

Posted October 26, 2011 at 9:58 AM (Answer #3)

dislike -1 like

The subject the introduction purports to deal with is interesting. However, the first paragrpgh, as an advance organizer, should have accomplished the function of offering a preview of the paper. First of all, the initial statement(Sentence 1) has not been supported by sentence 2 or 3. It begins by stating that the relationship between birth order and personality is interesting. Subsequent statements do not tell the reader why interesting the relationship is. Secondly, the introduction is overambitious by trying to accomplish several functions which other textual units must do. It introduces the subject, justifies the choice of the subject, states the hypothesis, states the purpose and the organizational principle to be followed. Thirdly, the use of reporting verbs, such as "suggested" are used inappropriately. Instead, I suggest the use of "argue" or "hypothesize".

Join to answer this question

Join a community of thousands of dedicated teachers and students.

Join eNotes