Home > Great Expectations Summary & Study Guide > Great Expectations Group > Discussion Board

  Personally, I think Pip is not innocent. However, my teacher says he is. Pip grows up in a society full of stereotypes, and therefore, cannot resist the temptations to fall victim of his "great expectations" and look down at Joe and Magwitch. However, in my opinion, if Joe was the one who got the "great expectations", Joe would not feel ashamed of having Pip and try to distance away from him. Also, looking down at someone who has given him money and risked his life to see him is definitely not innocent.

You are thinking like a reader. Everyone will always have his/her own opinion of a character's characteristics and moral fortitude. As far as you saying "...looking down at someone who has given him money and risked his life to see him is definitely not innocent." does cause me to believe that you have not finished the story yet. At the end, Pip talks about how he has this unparalleled love for Magwitch and is grateful to know him. He visits him in the hospital and takes care of him.

I have my students form their own opinion about the characters - whether they are innocent or not - based on their observations and textual evidence. If you feel as though Pip isn't innocent, your teacher will be receptive and appreciate your thinking outside the box as long as you back up what you say!