Criticism > Drama Criticism > Exiles, James Joyce - R. A. Maher (essay date 1972)
Exiles, James Joyce - R. A. Maher (essay date 1972)
R. A. Maher (essay date 1972)
SOURCE: Maher, R.A. “James Joyce's Exiles: The Comedy of Discontinuity.” James Joyce Quarterly 9, no. 4 (summer 1972): 461–74.
[In the following essay, Maher compares Exiles to Hamlet and examines the relationships of the characters in Exiles.]
Joyce described Exiles as “three cat and mouse acts” (Exiles 123); he also called it “a comedy in three acts” (Letters I, 78). The comedy of Exiles will not be felt, however, if we mistake the play for a drama of ideas. If we do, we are the mouse being teased by Joyce. The play is an extraordinarily tactile and auditory play: it shows everything and states nothing. Only if we assiduously avoid trying to make the play fit into a discursive framework, into some message Joyce is developing progressively act by act, will we hear and feel the comedy.
Furthermore, if we focus only on Richard as the hero of...
[The entire page is 5645 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
- Criticism: Production Reviews
-
Criticism: Critical Commentary
- Ezra Pound (review date 1916)
- Times Literary Supplement (review date 1918)
- Desmond MacCarthy (review date 1918)
- John Rodker, Israel Solon, Samuel A. Tannenbaum, and jh (essay date 1919)
- Francis Fergusson (essay date 1932)
- Bernard Bandler (essay date 1933)
- James Farrell (essay date 1948)
- Hugh Kenner (essay date 1956)
- Marvin Magalaner and Richard M. Kain (essay date 1956)
- Francis Fergusson (essay date 1957)
- D. J. F. Aitken (essay date 1958)
- William York Tindall (essay date 1959)
- Maurice Harmon (essay date 1965)
- Earl John Clark (essay date 1968)
- B. J. Tysdahl (essay date 1968)
- Bernard Benstock (essay date 1969)
- Edward Brandabur (essay date 1971)
- R. A. Maher (essay date 1972)
- John MacNicholas (essay date 1973)
- Theo Q. Dombrowski and Lester B. Pearson (essay date 1978)
- Carole Brown and Leo Knuth (essay date 1979)
- John MacNicholas (essay date 1981)
- Raymond Williams (essay date 1982)
- Bernard Benstock (essay date 1985)
- Suzette A. Henke (essay date 1990)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
