Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Zappa, Frank - Shel Kagan
Zappa, Frank - Shel Kagan
SHEL KAGAN
Though the title song [on Joe's Garage, Act 1] is a delightful history of every garage band that ever came out of rock & roll, the album is marred by a fault that has dogged Zappa's career since its beginning: sheer overindulgence. The narrative, otherwise perceptive and satiric, is weighed down with an overtext supplied by a computer voice dubbed The Central Scrutinizer, an icon which represents the establishment.
In both the album notes and the spoken narration, Zappa uses the Scrutinizer to say that higher authority is trying to a) do away with music; b) enslave the population through use of music. Forget the paradox; despite the pun (the Scrutinizer is screwing us, see?) these tract-like ravings don't in any way illuminate the high-schoolish (he admits it) plot.
Besides, with music co-opted by huge conglomerated labels, and with punk groups graduating to the money-making ranks of New Wave pop stardom, it's hard to...
[The entire page is 226 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Bertram Stanleigh
- Harvey Pekar
- Robert A. Rosenstone
- Ellen Sander
- David G. Walley
- Lester Bangs
- Alan Heineman
- Bill Reed
- Lester Bangs
- Lester Bangs
- Jay Cocks
- Dan Morgenstern
- David Reitman
- Mike Bourne
- David Walley
- Arthur Schmidt
- Peter Kountz
- Alan Niester
- Eric Salzman
- JOHN SWENSON and BART TESTA
- Lester Bangs
- Robert Duncan
- Andy Doherty
- Tim Schneckloth
- David Fricke
- Peter Reilly
- Jon Pareles
- Karl Dallas
- Shel Kagan
- Cole Springer
- Tom Carson
- Jon Pareles
- Don Shewey
- Larry Birnbaum
- Paul Tickell
- Copyright
