Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Waters, Frank - Fred T. Marsh (review date 23 June 1935)
Waters, Frank - Fred T. Marsh (review date 23 June 1935)
Fred T. Marsh (review date 23 June 1935)
SOURCE: "Colorado Boom Days," in The New York Times Book Review, June 23, 1935, pp. 6-7.
[In the review below, Marsh gives a mixed assessment of The Wild Earth's Nobility.]
Frank Waters has written one of those tales of the West which are competing with English, Scandinavian and other "sagas" for popularity with those who like long drawn out family histories. If it be true that every man's life has a novel in it, it is just as true that every family has the stuff out of which a saga (in the corrupted modern use of the word) may be fabricated. The American pioneer saga has its own virtues and its own defects. But all honest novels of pioneer families should be welcomed for theirs is the stuff out of which American society has been made.
Frank Waters's [The Wild Earth's Nobility] is a novel of the Colorado mining boom. It begins in the Seventies and runs through the early years of the...
[The entire page is 1074 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- The New York Times Book Review (review date 29 June 1930)
- Fred T. Marsh (review date 23 June 1935)
- Joseph Henry Jackson (review date 21 January 1940)
- Margaret Wallace (review date 9 February 1941)
- Burton Rascoe (review date 13 June 1942)
- Vernon Young (essay date Autumn 1949)
- William T. Pilkington (essay date August 1967)
- Thomas J. Lyon (essay date October 1967)
- Jack L. Davis and June H. Davis (essay date May 1974)
- John Milton (essay date Autumn 1977)
- Quay Grigg (essay date Autumn 1977)
- Christopher Hoy (essay date Autumn 1977)
- H. David Brumble III (essay date Spring 1980)
- Bob Gish (review date 20 December 1987)
- Charles L. Adams (essay date 1987)
- Alexander Blackburn (essay date Spring 1990)
- Scott Vickers (review date May-June 1993)
- Fergus M. Bordewich (review date March 1994)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
