Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Updike, John (Vol. 13) - Daphne Merkin

1. Printable Version
2. Download PDF
3. Cite this Page
4. Tweet This

DAPHNE MERKIN

[While] Updike is gifted at everything he puts his hand to, he is not equally gifted. Thus, although he is a first-rate miniaturist (his short stories are usually flawless, and his criticism can be truly remarkable …), he has failed to attain major status as a novelist. Perhaps his is a case of talent spread too thin to sustain the rigors of full-length fiction. Or perhaps something less tangible and more complicated is involved—a subtle clash between artistic ability and artistic inclination, between what John Updike is best equipped to write about and what he wants to write about. More specifically, he seeks to abandon his natural subjects—disgruntled marriages (Couples, Marry Me) and crumbling Wasp traditions (A Month of Sundays)—for darker, archetypal matters—alien accounts of wandering Jews (Bech: A Book) and militant blacks (Rabbit Redux). And these books of larger vision, despite not always being persuasive,...

Join eNotes

The above is a free excerpt. Get total access to this content with the:

eNotes Pass

1. Introduction
2. Victor Strandberg
3. Daphne Merkin
4. Robert Towers
5. John Thompson
6. Alastair Reid
7. Joyce Carol Oates
8. Gene Lyons
9. WILLIAM McPHERSON
10. Paul Theroux
11. Copyright

1. John Updike