Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Russo, Richard - John Simon (review date 6 April 1998)

1. Printable Version
2. Download PDF
3. Cite this Page

John Simon (review date 6 April 1998)

SOURCE: Simon, John. “Benton in Clover, Coens in Bilge.” National Review 50, no. 6 (6 April 1998): 58-9.

[In the following review, Simon compliments Twilight as a “rare crime story that makes sense.”]

Some years ago Robert Benton, Richard Russo, and Paul Newman came up with a winner, Nobody's Fool, and here they are with another one, Twilight, directed by Benton, co-written by him and Russo, and again starring Newman. This time, though, it's a very different story, about rich, amoral people in Los Angeles, part detective thriller, part romantic triangle (sort of), part chronicle of complicated friendships and betrayals, a way-we-live-now morality tale.

Adroitly mixed, these elements coexist remarkably. At the center is Harry Ross (Newman), once a cop, then a private eye, who manages to track down, in the film's prologue, the runaway daughter of wealthy Jack and...

Join eNotes

The above is a free excerpt. Get total access to this content with the:

eNotes Pass

1. Introduction
2. Principal Works
3. Criticism
   1. David Montrose (review date 6 March 1987)
   2. Richard Eder (review date 13 September 1988)
   3. Hilma Wolitzer (review date 30 October 1988)
   4. James McConkey (review date 27 November 1988)
   5. Betty Abel (review date April 1989)
   6. John Clute (review date 9-15 June 1989)
   7. E. Annie Proulx (review date 30 May 1993)
   8. Howard Frank Mosher (review date 6 June 1993)
   9. Wendy Smith (essay date 7 June 1993)
   10. Gail Caldwell (review date 27 June 1993)
   11. Roz Kaveney (review date 30 July 1993)
   12. Steve Brzezinski (review date winter 1994)
   13. M. R. Montgomery (essay date 26 January 1995)
   14. Scott Bradfield (review date 25 July 1997)
   15. Zoë Ingalls (essay date 8 August 1997)
   16. Thomas Curwen (review date 21 September 1997)
   17. Michael Lee (review date 26 September 1997)
   18. Ron Charles (review date 6 October 1997)
   19. Stanley Kauffmann (review date 30 March 1998)
   20. Jon Saari (review date spring 1998)
   21. John Simon (review date 6 April 1998)
   22. Rita D. Jacobs (review date autumn 1998)
   23. Ron Charles (review date 10 May 2001)
   24. Dan Cryer (review date 27 May-2 June 2001)
   25. James Marcus (review date June 2001)
   26. D. T. Max (review date 10 June 2001)
   27. Michael Prager (review date 27 June 2001)
   28. Don McCleese (review date July 2001)
   29. Bill Broun (review date 6 July 2001)
   30. Bruce Allen (review date 5 August 2001)
   31. Edward Hower (review date October 2001)
   32. Joseph Epstein (review date January 2002)
   33. Rita D. Jacobs (review date spring 2002)
   34. Kristen Case (review date July-August 2002)
   35. Peter Heinegg (review date 21 October 2002)
   36. Tom Deignan (review date November 2002)
4. Further Reading
5. Copyright