Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Ragni, Gerome - Clive Barnes
Ragni, Gerome - Clive Barnes
CLIVE BARNES
[This] godson of "Hair" never quite makes it. ["Dude"'s] pretensions are always clearer than its achievements, yet even those pretensions are not without a certain naiveté that might endear the show to some…. [Those] wonderful folks who gave us "Hair," here give us a brave try.
[Here] the lack of discipline to that imagination, a freedom that proved so charming in "Hair," chains the musical down instead of liberating it. In "Hair" the very aimlessness of the piece, its random poetry and shafts of insight could afford the luxury of a nonstructure because it was describing a life style that deliberately embraced nonstructured patterns as its aim. "Dude," on the other hand, seems to be an allegory about "that great theater in the sky," and an allegory that is not clear, even on its primary level, is in no end of trouble.
The idea of "Dude," or what I can make out of it, is both complex and simplistic. It is, I presume, an attempt to...
[The entire page is 246 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Clive Barnes
- Edith Oliver
- Howard Taubman
- Robert Brustein
- Henry Hewes
- Gerald Weales
- Clive Barnes
- William Kloman
- John Simon
- William F. Buckley, Jr.
- Theophilus Lewis
- Robert Kotlowitz
- Benedict Nightingale
- John Weightman
- Clive Barnes
- Gene Lees
- John Rockwell
- Peter Schjeldahl
- David Ewen
- Jonathan Swift
- Clive Barnes
- Walter Kerr
- Clive Barnes
- Walter Kerr
- Radcliffe Joe
- Richard Eder
- Brendan Gill
- John Simon
- Copyright
